Pelican: Crap or Not Crap?

Crap
Total votes: 6 (60%)
Not Crap
Total votes: 4 (40%)
Total votes: 10

Band: Pelican

1
Kerble as needed, but it doesn't appear the Pelican band thread made it to the new forum.

Anyway, I saw their first few records are getting reissued by Thrill Jockey this year, and the original line-up will be touring.

I am super stoked on this news.

Re: Band: Pelican

3
Not crap.

I dont think they are AMAZING, but I have seen them put on some good shows, seem like cool dudes, I also think their drummer gets dumped on too much. First 3 things they put out were enjoyable.
guitar in - weaklungband.bandcamp.com/

Re: Band: Pelican

7
Owen wrote: Fri Jan 21, 2022 5:18 pm I also think their drummer gets dumped on too much. First 3 things they put out were enjoyable.
Drumming sucks, really drags the whole thing down.

I do kinda like those first 3 records, they were being played a lot by my social circle at the time (ditto Isis). Neurosis / Godflesh etc were def a bridge too far for that crowd, which is telling in hindsight.

But while I wouldn't say it's bad, for a band operating in the paradigm of earlier innovators, it just ain't really good enough.

Crap

Re: Band: Pelican

8
I liked the first EP and Australasia. Once they got more into the delay pedal Explosions in the Sky kind of stuff I got pretty bored, and it exposed their rhythmic weakness even more. I never went back, but I know some trustworthy people who still praise them as a live band.

NC wf 8
Music

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests