I don't have an answer, maybe this forum can help.

Why these two exactly? They're pretty different!

Mooney probably has the greater comedy imagination though Davidson gets by on his lovable fuckup charm. I think he ended up in rehab again this week and I worry he'll end up being another Belushi/Farley..

Dunno. As far as recent cast I'm a fan of Sarah Sherman aka Sarah Squirm. Impressively disgusting stuff.

penningtron wrote: Thu Dec 28, 2023 2:16 pm Why these two exactly? They're pretty different!

Are they? I tend to find them both unfunny, hence the pairing, but it's all subjective.

Thinking deeper I laugh at Pete Davidson doing "Chad" but it's a challenge finding any Kyle Mooney skit uproarious. I'm really not aware of either's standup, so there is that.

Davidson, while inconsistent and occasionally insufferable, has participated in skits that have elicited belly laughs from me. I can't say the same for Mooney, at least nothing that I remember.

Davidson gets my vote.

rsmurphy wrote: Thu Dec 28, 2023 2:27 pm Thinking deeper I laugh at Pete Davidson doing "Chad" but it's a challenge finding any Kyle Mooney skit uproarious. I'm really not aware of either's standup, so there is that.

Not standup but Bupkis (Davidson) is pretty good. I wanted to like Mooney's saturday morning cartoon show more because an old friend did the music for it.

penningtron wrote: Thu Dec 28, 2023 2:16 pm
Dunno. As far as recent cast I'm a fan of Sarah Sherman aka Sarah Squirm. Impressively disgusting stuff.

Easily the best new cast member in years. Her body horror comedy stuff is great, but also love her Update appearances that involve just ragging on Colin Jost the whole time.

tried to watch kyle mooney and it just made me want nathan fielder.

pete davidson is a living walking train wreck. that's funny (until it's not).

hbiden@onlyfans.com wrote: Sun Dec 31, 2023 10:33 pm tried to watch kyle mooney and it just made me want nathan fielder.

pete davidson is a living walking train wreck. that's funny (until it's not).

I admire Steve's standard comment about Trainwreck Courtney:

"No comment."

InMySoul77 wrote: Mon Jan 01, 2024 1:56 am

hbiden@onlyfans.com wrote: Sun Dec 31, 2023 10:33 pm tried to watch kyle mooney and it just made me want nathan fielder.

pete davidson is a living walking train wreck. that's funny (until it's not).

I admire Steve's standard comment about Trainwreck Courtney:

"No comment."

Actually in retrospect it would have been much nicer to say "Courtney is a human being deserving of respect."

Mooney is kinda funny and smart methinks.

Davidson is not.

There are like 100 better cast members though.