18
by SecondEdition_Archive
A great band, but they had their problems. Inconsistent songwriting, mostly. They were hardly ever bad, but frequently they weren't more than all right: which should be enough, but considering the fact that their peaks (most of the first album, the mid-60's singles like "Tin Soldier" and "Itchycoo Park," the first half of Ogden's Nut Gone Flake) are huge, it really made me wonder why they couldn't concentrate more on tightening up their music. (The Small Faces documentary answered those questions for me: they were too busy dealing with a ludicrous, greedhead shark of a manager at first, and then trying to keep Andrew Oldham's mismanaged Immediate label afloat pretty much all by themselves after that, while Steve Marriott kept getting more and more pissed off that they weren't being taken seriously - talk about pressure...)
They had tons of energy, though, and unquestionably they were the defining Mod band. (The Who had started moving away from the Mod image by the second album. I don't think the Small Faces did.)
Steve Marriott was one of the best vocalists the '60's ever produced. The guy could sing. Marriott's guitar playing, while nowhere near as good from a technical level as, say, Townshend, was nevertheless really exciting, jagged, and loud at its' best - qualities you could also attribute to Kenney Jones' fantastic drum bashing. Ronnie Lane and Ian McLagan really were secret weapons - Lane was, off and on, a great songwriter, and how many other bands could say they had their own R & B piano player and psychedelic organist in one guy? Not that many, if you think about it.
They also made a graceful and fascinating transition to psychedelic music - I doubt Parklife and Modern Life is Rubbish would have existed without them.
They're definitely Not Crap, but they're somewhat dated now in ways that, say, the Beatles aren't, and I do think they didn't have it as together as they could have, but still, that wasn't really their fault.
Life...life...I know it's got its ups and downs.
Groucho Marx wrote:Politics is the art of looking for trouble, finding it, misdiagnosing it and then misapplying the wrong remedies.