BadComrade wrote:I think what it comes down to is that I just hate "scenes". I'm not saying that my point of view should be the norm here... that's why I asked if people were going and what they thought of it.
Fests like this one / Lollapalooza / etc just seem to use peoples taste in music to create these large scenster events, so they can make money. Pitchfork are going to make a -lot- of money doing this, right? I mean, I might think a little differently of this kind of thing if they did it in a "non-profit" kind of way, yet made sure that the bands all got paid well, etc. It just seems like a big scam. To me, paying to get in to a fest like this one is like paying $20 to get in to a dance club. The people that pay to get in to those places do so because they want to feel like they're part of some "select group" of people, and they make the club owners rich in the process. I don't view regular rock club shows as being in the same vein as these fests, because 3 bands playing a show is a smaller, more focused thing. When you book a fest that has multiple stages, and a wide variety of bands that almost no one is going to like more than 25% of, it just seems like the promoter is casting a large net out to try and "catch" as many people as he can, so he can take their money from them, and make them feel like they are part of "something really cool and special" in the process.
I don't have a soul.
I think you make an excellent point...
...You don't have a soul (see what I did there?).
I also think if you asked the people who are going to the pitchfork festival if they hate "scenes" they would agree. I just like to think of 'scene' as a stupid, useless term that would most likely be reified by every person you ask. Yeah, everyone hates "scenes" and "hipsters," but everyone fits into those categories to a degree, anyway, whether they want to or not.
If there were enough bands playing that I would want to see, it makes sense to pay $20 to see them instead of $8-$15 for each at different times and in different venues. I don't hate Pitchfork enough to deprive myself of good music, but I do recognize the business mentality that you so eloquently pointed out, and I really disrespect that.
I too, have no soul. I have negative soul.