kinda good, kinda not...

you make the call!!

After seeing the miniseries and the first couple episodes of the first season, i gove it a solid NOT CRAP.

Utterly entertaining for the first season + 3/4ths of the second season 9haven't finished watching all of season 2.5 yet) save for maybe two episodes.

what an awesome show. Usually I hate Science fiction TV. This is the exception.



NC


also, Edward James Olmos.


also, 'Chief' Tyrol looks like Angus Jung.

i saw just the first episode where they have to kill all the peoples of a ship just because of a ennemy inside them....whaaa!! not crap !

kerble wrote:what an awesome show. Usually I hate Science fiction TV. This is the exception.

Did you like or hate Firefly? I forget. I ask because i love that they are using the special effects crew from Firefly, and thus, are using the Firefly-esque hand-held camera in space shots that i love love love.

Also, i'm really digging Col. Tigh so far. Ten-hut, Colonel Whiskey!

not familiar at all with Firefly.

BSG, she is not crap.

The first pseudo-season/mini-series was great. Seen 1/3 of the first official season and thought it was very good.

Cylon Lady snaps a baby's neck! Jeebus!

A very cool show! And on the fucking Sci-Fi channel!? WTF?!

Very Not Crap. A very surprisingly good show.


Could do with more tension around the "who is a cylon?" plot line.

Not crap. I just saw the first hour or so of the pilot and I'm already hooked!

This show is incredible.

One of my top picks as good as The Shield and Deadwood, better than The Sopranos and Lost.


And I really like The Sopranos and Lost.


Also:

Firefly is a great great one season TV show set in a Sci-Fi cowboyish mercenary pirate (Han Solo-ish) kind of setting. Well acted and written (Joss Whedon), culminates in an excellend movie called Serenity