swans

crap
Total votes: 2 (4%)
not crap
Total votes: 42 (81%)
it all depends on whether jarboe is on the record
Total votes: 8 (15%)
Total votes: 52

band: swans

21
placeholder wrote:I voted "it all depends on whether jarboe is on the record", but what I really mean is "it all depends on whether Jarboe is singing". God, I loathe her highschool drama-club theatrics. The song "Hypogirl" alone is almost enough to put me off on Swans, and may have the silliest, yet most irritating vocals I have ever heard.

Swans, though, are still NOT CRAP. I just skip the Jarboe songs.


gira doesn't engage in highschool drama club theatrics? jesus. he's one melodramatic motherfucker. jarboe can really, really sing. i think their version of "cry me a river" which she sings is probably my favorite swans song.

band: swans

25
trilonaut wrote: gira doesn't engage in highschool drama club theatrics? jesus.


Angry_Dragon wrote: When they were on tour with Sonic Youth in 83 or around there, in the middle of a song Gira jumps off stage and beats a kid up. He gets back on stage and apologizes to the kid and says I'm sorry, but you were having too much fun.
Rotten Tanx wrote: every time I watch Die Hard (6am and 8pm, mon to sat)...

band: swans

26
rzs wrote:
trilonaut wrote: gira doesn't engage in highschool drama club theatrics? jesus.


Angry_Dragon wrote: When they were on tour with Sonic Youth in 83 or around there, in the middle of a song Gira jumps off stage and beats a kid up. He gets back on stage and apologizes to the kid and says I'm sorry, but you were having too much fun.


am i supposed to read that as "yes, he does engage in high school drama club theatrics" or "he's a tough asshole, unlike high school drama club members"?

i'd call that drama club theatrics crossed with jock assholeishness, not exactly a winning combination. funny story, though.

band: swans

30
Swans is one of those bands that took a bit to grow on me. It's some of the most punishing, confrontational, disturbing, incredibly creative music to come out of anywhere in the past 30 years.

I think Gira is great, and his work with Angels of Light is nothing to sneer at. A very talented fellow.

Some of the shit on his website is a bit overpriced though, but I'm pretty sure it's just to keep Young God afloat.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests