Faulkner or Hemingway?

Ernerst Hemingway
Total votes: 10 (31%)
William Faulkner
Total votes: 22 (69%)
Total votes: 32

Literary Mans: Faulkner vs Hemingway

12
Imagine how I felt when he brought up Beavis and Butthead for the first time. This is a balding guy in his fifties given to wearing vests and bolo ties with turquoise clasps. He's also nearly completely deaf and wears hearing aids in both ears. Not the picture of a hard rock fan.

Then he explained that B&B often played the first video from "my daughter's band." This was for "Highway 65". He told me he'd go to her early shows to support her, but turn his hearing aids off. He also said Rob Zombie was a very friendly, sweet guy who he really liked.
You had me at Sex Traction Aunts Getting Vodka-Rogered On Glass Furniture

Literary Mans: Faulkner vs Hemingway

14
We talking as novelists? Yeah. Faulkner. Easy.

But Christ, Papa wrote some mindblowing short fiction.

Sure, you can trace them back to Sherwood Anderson or even Chekhov, but his contribution to the form is inestimable. I don't think many people would deny that. They're all stories that will stay with me until the day I die; utter perfection and I can't go more than a few weeks without taking a few tokes from my Complete Hemingway paperback.

"Indian Camp," "The Killers," "In Another Country," "The Light of the World," "A Day's Wait."

But then again, I go completely apeshit for good short fiction.

His novels ain't bad either (particularly the concluding tense-as-all-hell chapters of For Whom the Bell Tolls).

Literary Mans: Faulkner vs Hemingway

20
Skuldt wrote:William Faulkner's NY Times obituary, in the archives, is one of my favorites. JFK invited Faulkner--who had just won a Nobel prize--to dine at the White House, and Faulkner turned him down, because, in his opinion, "eighty miles is an awfully long way to go for dinner."

Hemingway didn't do anything *that* funny.
Excellent.

Faulkner for me. Hemmingway is great, but Faulkner is a step up.

I don't like Melville at all, his place in the canon be damned. Boring.
http://www.myspace.com/leopoldandloebchicago

Linus Van Pelt wrote:I subscribe to neither prong of your false dichotomy.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests