BadComrade wrote:

mw wrote:who is saying the albums "recorded at Electrical" aren't " really produced"?

Well, I'm pretty sure Steve would. He isn't a "producer", which is why he refers to himself as an engineer.

A producer usually has a lot of input on the sound of a band on record. Watch the documentary of the making of Aerosmith's album Pump for example, and you'll see the producer telling them to change lyrics, guitar parts, etc. Listen to an album recorded by Phil Spector, and you'll hear the "Phil Spector sound". The only thing on a recording that might give away the fact that Steve recorded it is the sound of the drums, and that's not even always the case.

glueman wrote:Well, I think that at the very least, we can all agree that Momentary Lapse of Reason is perfectly produced and recorded

Pure L wrote:

glueman wrote:Well, I think that at the very least, we can all agree that Momentary Lapse of Reason is perfectly produced and recorded

.......it's just that the songs suck.

BadComrade wrote:*sigh*

You said that glueman was "so, so wrong" when he pointed to the list of bands recorded at Electrical. I said he was only "wrong" in the sense that they haven't been "produced". I never implied that you were saying Steve or any of the other engineers at Electrical did a "shit job".

Also, Pink Floyd is not perfection.

scott wrote:Piper At The Gates Of Dawn.

Great production.

As time went on, their production got a little too "big production" for me. I still like it, but as the kids say, I liked their earlier stuff better.