Crap/Not Crap

Crap
Total votes: 6 (55%)
Not Crap
Total votes: 5 (45%)
Total votes: 11

Movie: Closer

22
sparky wrote:
Tree wrote:This is the type of movie where if a friend of mine said they like it, I would literally lose a little respect for them as a person. Not respect for their tastes, respect for them as a whole person.


Why?

I've found that people who like this movie either "identify with the characters" or "wish people talked like that". I didn't find the characters to be "flawed", I found them to be "despicable" and "vapid". Kind of like a negative of Seinfeld, but with coarse language.

The thought of wishing people talked like that kind of gives me the willies. I'm not sure what I'd think if I heard somebody say the type of stuff Clive Owen says, I'd have to get back to you on that. I don't think I could stand a world where people talk that much.

Movie: Closer

23
Some nice lines in it, sure. But the story boils down to stripper with a heart of gold bullshit. Oh Jude Law, you had the perfect sex worker companion, but you threw it away for a fling with a woman who looks like Lyle Lovett.
"It was not a significant bullet."

Movie: Closer

25
tommydski wrote:Wait, let me check.
The cast was -

Jude Law
Julia Roberts
Clive Owen

This was something that someone sat through?
Like, for money?


My ex-fiance made me do it. Honest. I had warned her in advance that it was unlikely to be a cuddly date movie.

Movie: Closer

28
Tree wrote:Did Natalie Portman's list of cinematic masterpieces prompt you to leave her off this list?

Yeah I don't think she's a particularly good actress but I don't hate her.
She seems amusing and articulate in person.

The other three would put me off almost any film.
run joe run wrote:Kerble your enthusiasm.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests