Elliott Smith?

Not Crap
Total votes: 49 (79%)
Crap
Total votes: 13 (21%)
Total votes: 62

Artist: Elliott Smith

21
kenoki wrote:
Eierdiebe wrote:II like the "Needle in the Hay"/suicide sequence in the Royal Tennenbaums quite a lot. That was an impeccable choice of music on Anderson's part.


i agree, in a movie that was easy to despise here and there, that scene got me and i'm sure it had plenty to do with the elliot smith...

I opened this thread to say just that. The last line of the last verse -- "so leave me alone, you oughta be proud 'cause I'm getting good markssssssss" -- is some kind of exemplar of how incredible sadness and anger can be conveyed very quietly.

Other than that, kinda meh and often overly twee to my ears except for a few standouts like "St. Ides Heaven" and "Junk Bond Trader." The piano at the beginning of the latter tends to induce severe Elton John flashbacks, but a great song even so. Not crap, high WF.
Last edited by ctrl-s_Archive on Thu Mar 08, 2007 3:33 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest