Choose one

Rib Eye
Total votes: 9 (41%)
New York
Total votes: 13 (59%)
Total votes: 22

Battle Of The Steaks Rib Eye or New York?

22
Cooking a steak that fine (and that expensive) to medium is a crime. Cooking to medium will render all those delectable veins of fat, which are the entire point of this particular type of beef, so you just wind up with a firm, more or less ordinary steak.

Putting oil and Worcestershire on it isn't much better.

Beef patrol!
You had me at Sex Traction Aunts Getting Vodka-Rogered On Glass Furniture

Battle Of The Steaks Rib Eye or New York?

27
If I had enough determination to just start cooking steaks in my own little pathetic kitchen, I maybe wouldn't have to refer to the hanger steak I had at the Yellow Brick Bank in Shepherdstown, WV, in 2002. I can't remember the details (sides), but the steak was memorable. Quite memorable.

Maybe not as memorable as the Steak Tartare at Park No. 9 in Boston, but that's another steak story (or thread).

Battle Of The Steaks Rib Eye or New York?

28
The Flatiron steak has it all.
Loads of flavor.
Great marbling.
Nice texture.
Tender, but not in that bullshit filet mignon way.

I usually just Florentine one - nice and simple.

It's not expensive and I have no idea why. Like the Hanger, it was considered junk. When polled, however, butchers regularly listed it as the best or second best piece of meat on the beast.

Sometimes you can find them at Whole Foods or any decent butcher. It's about $8 a pound.

And I do love a good Hanger steak.

-A
Itchy McGoo wrote:I would like to be a "shoop-shoop" girl in whatever band Alex Maiolo is in.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests