tmidgett wrote:But the band that played Bush's inauguration party qualifies on a list of Republican bands.
or else they qualify as mercenaries, but we're not talking about mercenaries
i say off the list. if someone asked billy gibbons personally and he said 'no, i am not a republican,' off the list. if someone can ask frank beard and dusty hill, that would be great. you don't have to bag the whole band.
First, the fervent Christians need not be Republican. Granted, I don't think anyone's explicitly said so. But these days, I'm of the opininion that it's good to forcefully herald the Left's long and proud tradition with a revolutionary social message in the Gospels. Mennonites, Liberation Theologians and Dorothy Day all serve as easy examples.
Second, you are wrong, Tim. You don't need to twist the understanding of the term Republican to make a clear argument that the band playing Bush's "Welcome to the White House" party is a Republican band. They've got the event on their website. They gave the dude signed guitars. I don't have to ask the band - they've shown me that they're a Republican band. There are many Republicans who don't like Bush's subsequent record and who think that the Dixie Chicks thing is stupid. But that doesn't meant that they're not Republicans.
Second and a half, I actually think that there's a case of Maria Shriver being a Republican. Maybe I'm too inclined to see guilt by association.
(Third, I actually don't think that Tim is really wrong, but I want to have baited him enough for a response. As I write this, he's at exactly 50% over 666. And I want to see him hit 4 digits.)
= Justin