Excellent or Crap.

Excellent
Total votes: 119 (84%)
Crap.
Total votes: 22 (16%)
Total votes: 141

Album: Excellent Italian Greyhound

115
I can't vote. Neither excellent nor crap. It's all waffle.

I like a few of the songs alot. Stuff like 'Genuine Lulabelle' I will likley never warm to.

I have never been a fan of 'The End of Radio,' so I suppose that disqualifies some of my lack of enthusiasm.

I can see how 'Hold On' might not have translated in the studio. I don't miss it.

This seems like leftovers. Songs that are 10 years old, songs that are 7 years old or more. The listening experience lacks the fun of discovery as I am familiar with almost everything on the disc.

I understand the modus operandi of recording and touring when you can, of embracing a lofty and consistent day-to-day work ethic that does not always accomodate a life centered around being in a band. That's life and it's great and I applaud. Still, EIG makes me think that said approach doesn't keep the blood pressure up, if you know what I mean. Treating the band like an obligation, like a job you don't really care that much about is a pitfall. Sure. But so is treating it like a habitual hobby. I am not saying that such is what Shellac has done, but, to my ears, the record seems a bit stale and unfocused.

Waffle.

Album: Excellent Italian Greyhound

116
I haven't heard the record, as I'd really like to buy it legally. However, I do not know of a single independant record store near me (minus a combo instrument/recording gear/record shop that focuses on jazz). I CANNOT FIND THIS RECORD. Shit. I'm gonna have to order it on the futureweb.

On a side note, anyone know of any good record stores in western essx county New Jersey?
What are the queers doing to the soil?

Album: Excellent Italian Greyhound

117
I'm thinking as I listen to "End of Radio" and "Lulabelle," Probably gonna skip these next time I listen - and those two songs are like half the record. They're novelty songs, and I've heard these long, drawn-out, lots of empty space -type songs before. It reminds me of Terraform, some good moments and a lot of boring parts. Call me unimaginative, but I still like the early singles and At Action Park best. And blah blah blah you can tell me Shellac don't care if I like the record and that's fine. I wanted to hear it, I bought it, I like parts of it, but I'll probably never love it.

The LP packaging is wonderful, though.

Album: Excellent Italian Greyhound

120
STF wrote:I'm thinking as I listen to "End of Radio" and "Lulabelle," Probably gonna skip these next time I listen - and those two songs are like half the record. They're novelty songs, and I've heard these long, drawn-out, lots of empty space -type songs before. It reminds me of Terraform, some good moments and a lot of boring parts. Call me unimaginative, but I still like the early singles and At Action Park best. And blah blah blah you can tell me Shellac don't care if I like the record and that's fine. I wanted to hear it, I bought it, I like parts of it, but I'll probably never love it.

The LP packaging is wonderful, though.


The songs on their own are great, but they fucking ruin the record.

I've mentioned this before...early '80s speed metal taught me never to open a record with a slow song.

I've skipped End of Radio and Lulabelle each time I've listened, but when I do listen to them I really like the songs.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests