Straight edge?

CRAP?
Total votes: 46 (75%)
NOT CRAP?
Total votes: 15 (25%)
Total votes: 61

Ethos: straight edge

21
chalst wrote:As pioneered by Ian MacKaye: abstention from alcohol, drugs, sex; self-reliance; healthy mind and healthy body; vegetarianism, etc.


I've always disagreed with vegatarianism being lumped in with stright edge. I've known plenty of pot smoking smelly hippes that are vegetarian. I myself am vegetarian and have never been stright edge. I've known many a fat-guy-hardcore-staright-edge guys who eat burgers like there is no tomorrow.

I can't understand how vegetarianism gets lumped in with edge.
Gatehouse Anchor

Live From the Fallout Shelter

Ethos: straight edge

22
As a denizen of the #1 Binge-drinking city in the country (an act I consider to be very, very, very stupid), I can admire straight edge.

But I don't really see a need to take what should be "moderation" to an almost fascistic, labeled extreme. Plus, I think the last thing most people need in their lives is celibacy.

But if it gets kids thinking about things like "say, why IS it cool to drink shitty beer until I puke (and then drink some more)?", then I think that's good.

This brings up one of my biggest pet peaves: a group of people getting stoned together only to talk solely about marijuana. Botany. To me, this is akin to getting a pizza with some friends only to talk about different forms of dough-preparation.

Not Crap. Heavy waffle factor.

Connor

Ethos: straight edge

23
connor wrote:This brings up one of my biggest pet peaves: a group of people getting stoned together only to talk solely about marijuana. Botany. To me, this is akin to getting a pizza with some friends only to talk about different forms of dough-preparation.


Dude, you're bumming my trip. Today's forecast is gonna be mooooooostly cloudy with a hiiiiigh around 420. Strong chance of BRAINstorms, maaaan...

Ethos: straight edge

25
Straight Edge (capital S and E), as a boy's club, is CRAP.

But the "ethos", I think, is NOT CRAP, which is what I voted for.

I myself am "straight edge", but always cringe when I have to use the term. Preaching about it, or bringing it up out of nowhere, is crap, and most straight edge people that I know would "abstain" from such behavior.

And anyway, historically, abstinence from sex was never the rule... it was about not being promiscuous.

And vegeterianism, and then veganism, became extensions of straight edge, because they furthered purity in diet and of the body.

Ethos: straight edge

29
wiggins wrote:something particularly stands out from the instrument dvd:
"you do not beat up people period"


I was in a band that opened for Minor Threat a couple of times. Before we played with them at the Jockey Club in Newport, Kentucky, we found out that our drummer's girlfriend had been fucking a dude from a rival Lexington band while she was away at college. This caused a huge feud between two scenes that already loathed each other. During our set, I went off between songs, trashing Lexington punks and challenging anybody who didn't like it to come see me after the show. This may or may not have been the gig where I hurled a folding chair into the pit, hitting a number of people, then leapt from the stage, set the chair up, and stood upon it for the rest of the song, daring anyone to come within swinging distance.

By the time Minor Threat took the stage, there was a LOT of bad blood in the audience. This was the last show of the band's 'Out of Step' tour, and they were exhausted and in no mood for bullshit. I'm not sure what happened--I think he might have been spat upon--but at one point, Ian said, "You motherfucker!" and absolutely clocked this guy in front of the stage. He then ranted for a while about assholes before launching back into the song. Need I add that they were an amazing band.

After the show, we were totally fucking with Ian, saying "You're a fucking bad ass, Ian. You fucked that dude up. You're the enforcer." He was totally embarrassed and apologetic, but, it was obvious, far from emasculated by his monastic regimen. And nobody--not even Ian MacKaye--minds being called a bad ass by a bunch of greasy rednecks.

Ethos: straight edge

30
Justin from Queens wrote:Not Crap, because it produced a poll that had this in one of the responses.

How the hell else are you gonna be able to fuck good as an adult if you don't fuck bada few times as a teen?


That's great.

= Justin


he's probably right--i was a straight edge teen, and i still fuck pretty bad

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests