Excellent or Crap.

Excellent
Total votes: 119 (84%)
Crap.
Total votes: 22 (16%)
Total votes: 141

Album: Excellent Italian Greyhound

212
garble wrote:It's one of the editor's choices on allmusic at the moment:

http://allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sq ... fwxzu5ldse


Thanks for posting that link. The AMG and Trouser Press books used to be my only music resources as a 15-year-old back in '93 before the internet existed in any meaningful form.

Useful as they may be/may have been, I've always found it interesting that both guides tend to characterize stuff I really like as "filler" or "not up to par with the rest of the band's material." It happens again and again.

For that reason, I can't say I was that surprised when I saw this:

AMG wrote:Part two kicks off with "Genuine Lulabelle," and its random silences and oddly placed comic voices mark it as the album's only real misstep,


To me, the combination of these elements really made the song. As Shellac listeners, we've all heard random silences in songs before. But inserting soundbites of strange voices into those empty spaces is a move one would hardly expect from Shellac. It gave the song an enigmatic quality, and left me with a disquieting feeling of uncertainty which stayed with me long after the track had ended. The mark of a masterpiece.
[/quote]

Album: Excellent Italian Greyhound

214
Okay so, I listened to this in one go on Saturday when I thought I was dying.

It was all great then we came to the penultimate track which I liked then I hated then I liked then I loved then the very last bit just really didn't need to be there in my opinion so..there.

The last song was the rotten cherry on the stale cake. I'm just speaking of the last 4 bars of the penultimate songa and the last song. Or however you want to phrase it.

NC with dirty waffles.
Tom wrote: I remember going in the back and seeing him headbanging to Big Black. He looked like he was raping the air- really. He had this look on his face like, "yeah air... you know you want it.".

Album: Excellent Italian Greyhound

218
A great record. One of their best... To be honest I just really like what they do 99% of the time. It seems as genuine as a band can be. Inventive arrangements, Steve's darkhorse humour, the recording is magical. Beautiful packing - my girlfriend now wants an Italian Greyhound and has the record sleeve on our mantelpiece.

...and it's a grower.

And is it just me or does Paco sound very similar to another Shellac song?

Excellent.
Reality

Popular Mechanics Report of 9-11

NIST Investigation of the World Trade Center Disaster

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests