crap/not crap

crap
Total votes: 5 (10%)
not crap
Total votes: 47 (90%)
Total votes: 52

band:Melt Banana

32
NOT CRAP

not even close to crap, one of my favorite bands.

I like Speak, Squeak, Creak a real lot, I think it is the first full length. More extended techniques and strange playing on guitar and less pedals than the later stuff. Really cool record. Recorded by Albini and it sounds great.

The last song is the previous 24 all played at the same time.

band:Melt Banana

34
Completely NOT CRAP.

Ichirou Agata is one of the few "current" noise-rock guitarist that has a distinguishable style, and Sudoh Toshiaki was pretty kick-ass drummer, in any respect. They were noisy but never unnecessarily so, which means goddamn good, in my book.

Charlie was their best album, closely followed by Scratch or Stitch. They're newer ones like Bambi's Dilemma and Cell-Scape was better than "ok".

band:Melt Banana

35
thebronzemedal wrote:Completely NOT CRAP.

Ichirou Agata is one of the few "current" noise-rock guitarist that has a distinguishable style,


Fast "strumming" (I'll be more specific. Listen to "Rough dogs have bumps" off of Scratch or Stitch) usually sounds like limp-wristed filler to me. He does NOT sound limp-wristed.

band:Melt Banana

36
Skronk wrote:I think they're one of the best Japanese bands ever.


i'd be interested to know your others as i have become semi obsessed with a hand full of bands from Japan...

Ohkami No Jikan and Mainliner are tops in my books.

i have not actually heard much Melt Banana but will investigate post haste.

band:Melt Banana

38
I have a friend, a classical cellist, who took up bass guitar because seeing Melt Banana live made him want to be in a rock band.

For that alone, Not Crap.
Life...life...I know it's got its ups and downs.

Groucho Marx wrote:Politics is the art of looking for trouble, finding it, misdiagnosing it and then misapplying the wrong remedies.

band:Melt Banana

39
Germ War wrote:
coach wrote:Bump.

Not crap. Cell Scape is flat-out the best alarm clock ever. You need to get something done? Put Cell Scape on.


Cell-Scape is GREAT, but also the last I've heard from these guys. Haven't really thought about them in recent years. Great band, though.


Bambi's Dilemma came out last year and was their first full-length of new material since Cell-Scape. It sort of continues the progression they were making of moving into a more poppier direction...that is, what passes for "pop" in the Melt-Banana universe, of course.

Choppy just got their contribution to the Dark Beloved Cloud singles series, and it contains a studio recording of their cover of Devo's "Uncontrollable Urge." It is completely unfuckwithable.
http://www.ifihadahifi.net
http://www.superstarcastic.com

Marsupialized wrote:Thank you so much for the pounding, it came in handy.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests