I am only talking about the first album (and half of the second).
NOT CRAP definitely

Though the things they have done late give me stomach cramps.

not crap

I actually liked the last record American Supreme, so crap it was not crap

but yeah overall, not crap

and whaddya mean half of the second one? that record is great! so sick

very much not crap. the first two albums are brilliant, and they are still a great live band. sure, their stuff after the second record is very hit-or-miss (read: mostly crap), but i'd still give them an emphatic not crap vote.

aaand i liked a lot of 'american supreme', even though a couple of the songs sounded more something that, i don't know, m.c. skat kat or the new kids on the block should be singing on, rather than alan vega.

so, yeah. not crap.

i wont comment/vote on suicide, but the keyboardist's new solo album suuuuucks.

oscar ruiz wrote:I am only talking about the first album (and half of the second).

This defeats the purpose of the game.

The sentence "Raging against the cappucino machine" or the combination of words like "disney, dachau, disco" qualify the new record as not crap.
Ever got lost with your car in suburban city in an east european country listening to "Frankie teardrop" on the car stereo? How not crap is that?

I haven't heard the new record but I sure do get a kick out of the old stuff. The new one would have to suck real hard to erase the good feelings I get from those yelps and screeches. NOT CRAP.

Frankie Teardrop stills gives me the chills...

frankie teardrop was the first song that genuinely scared me.

i think i was asleep; it woke me up and i was scared shitless.

i don't really like them but they're definitely not crap.

Suicide are one of those bands that show the cruel side of the Crap/Not Crap game.
if you only consider the first Suicide album (a masterpiece,IMHO),the band comes across as being not crap.but if you take in condiseration their other releases and the atrocious shows...crap.

other bands i feel uncomfortable judging as crap/not crap are
The Cure
Dinosaur JR
Devo

solo artists
Caetano Veloso
David Bowie
Pino Daniele
and,well, basically every solo artist in the world!