Pan and zoom for days, what of it?

Crap
Total votes: 2 (22%)
Not Crap
Total votes: 7 (78%)
Total votes: 9

Re: Less-than-kinetic documentarian: Ken Burns.

4
Mr. Burns ( i love typing that ) can be soothing. Fast forward a decade and the story changes somewhat:

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/ar ... es/618395/

Like, not everything has to be about everything. But making a doc on the national parks - in 2009 - without dedicating an entire segment to native use of the land and subsequent violent removal is like making the Civil War doc without mentioning slavery.

I would like to go back and watch the Civil War again to see what is missing, but I know that's not likely to happen.

Re: Less-than-kinetic documentarian: Ken Burns.

5
NC with waffles. "Jazz" is too narrow, cosy, denigrating the weird. Jazz to be enjoyed from the armchair, but still enjoyable. "Vietnam" moved and mesmerised me. I haven't seen anything else, but this LRB article offers convincing criticism.
Alex Abramovich wrote:And Burns isn’t much of a filmmaker, either. All those static shots and slow pans over still images; the soothing pace of his films and their lulling, hypnotic effect make the viewer feel safe, smart and well cushioned whenever sore subjects are raised. Time and again, the sore subject is race, which Burns sees (again, to his credit) as central to the American story. But where a documentary filmmaker like Frederick Wiseman, who has his own long-standing relationship with PBS, questions things as they are at every turn, Burns makes films that are composed, entirely, of flat declarative statements. (Not once, in the course of Country Music, or any other Burns film I can think of, does the narrator pause to ask a question.) It’s not that his documentaries are as conservative formally as they end up being politically. It’s that, inadvertently, the two end up being one and the same. If you’re looking to question the status quo – which is to say, white supremacy – don’t.
The whole piece is thoughtful and worth a read.
Gib Opi kein Opium, denn Opium bringt Opi um!

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest