Kniferide wrote: Mon Oct 21, 2024 11:16 am
Question. P Bass pickup. Humbucker? or just 2 opposite wound single coils place right next to each other, one for each pair of strings? The pairs only pass over one of the coils each, so is that truly a Humbucker or is it not?
Semantics.
From an engineering perspective, it's cancelling hum, so it's technically a humbucker.
From a marketing, cataloging, traditional guitarist perspective, I think a "humbucker" implies that each string passes over two pole pieces that are transducing the string movement into electricity. This is why terms like noiseless, split coil, and hum cancelling are used. Because, to 95% of players, humbucker implies that your string is passing over two coils. Also, it operates on that original Seth Lover design of two coils that are RWRP in series.
So, everyone is kinda right. You just have to know the audience with whom you are speaking and use the term that will make them most likely to know what you are talking about.