Display posts from previous
Sort by

Dark Side of the Moon

Bongwater (C)
Total votes: 6 (21%)
Bongfuel (NC, WF)
Total votes: 14 (48%)
Underrated (NC, no WF)
Total votes: 9 (31%)
Why are you listening to Pink Floyd, dude? (No votes)
Total votes: 29

Re: Album: Dark Side of the Moon

81 by dontfeartheringo
gotdamn wrote: Mon Feb 10, 2025 5:53 am Roger Waters wrote a half-assed song on Piper that the band would use to jam, because it was like a verse and a half with some goofy ass beat. If I remember correctly, the version that made the album was actually trimmed down. That guy was not responsible for early Floyd's success (Syd's girlfriend sleeping with the UFO Club manager may have more to do with it than any musical chops). Richard Wright submitted the great track "Remember A Day" which Nick Mason couldn't play - the producer had to jump on the tubs to get it recorded. They would have been a pretty middling band if not for Syd's songwriting, wild rhythm guitar playing, and penchant for jamming; that last bit they would incorporate with Gilmour to try and write jams, a musical sin but Floyd fans love it. As it goes. Their recovery from losing Syd is laudable and Gilmour is a fine legato player, but not having been a teenager in the 70's, I can never buy into someone whose funk hand is as wooden as "Another Brick In The Wall" as a musical genius.

"Effervescent Elephant" is a children's song for sure, and its inclusion over other songs Syd had written at the time still seems kinda perplexing. Now, that said, it's far from as goofy as whatever the fuck Waters is on about with The Wall. The humor, playfulness, occasionally creepy adolescent vibes that crept into the music were not missteps. Hell, those are core tenant to good rock 'n roll! Prog rock's failure to understand that is one of the reasons it's gone the way of the dodo whilst there will always be a trashy band trying to resurrect The Cramps. I bet they could have rocked a very warped version of "See Emily Play."
Why do all Syd apologists write like this
tbone wrote: Sun Dec 10, 2023 11:58 pm I imagine at some point as a practicality we will all start assuming that this is probably the last thing we gotta mail to some asshole.

Re: Album: Dark Side of the Moon

82 by PASTA
JohnAlbert wrote: Mon Feb 10, 2025 7:27 am
rsmurphy wrote: Mon Feb 10, 2025 6:54 am
JohnAlbert wrote: Mon Feb 10, 2025 3:04 am "See Emily Play" is another one that seems like twee garbage.
This is actually one of my favorite early PF/Syd songs. It is a nice song.
I'll give it another listen. I'm not really big into that '60s psychedelic pop though.

I forgot to mention it, but "Bike" is the one that really grates on my nerves.
Wow John, wow, I love "Emily" "Bike" and "Gnome" as just nice little ditties in between psych "freak outs". Early Floyd is really some of the only '60s psychedelic pop I
like if I think on it though .
PRACTICE MINDFULNESS
DISPLAY ADAPTABILITY
FLEX YOUR HEAD

Re: Album: Dark Side of the Moon

83 by Wood Goblin
JohnAlbert wrote: Mon Feb 10, 2025 7:27 am
rsmurphy wrote: Mon Feb 10, 2025 6:54 am
JohnAlbert wrote: Mon Feb 10, 2025 3:04 am "See Emily Play" is another one that seems like twee garbage.
This is actually one of my favorite early PF/Syd songs. It is a nice song.
I'll give it another listen. I'm not really big into that '60s psychedelic pop though.

I forgot to mention it, but "Bike" is the one that really grates on my nerves.
Are you thinking of a different song? “See Emily Play” (which I love) is definitely psychedelic, but it’s pretty hard for a pop song, and I wouldn’t characterize it as twee.

As for DSOM, not crap, I suppose, though it’s so worn out that I’m likely to change the station when one of its tracks pops up.

Some of Gilmour’s best-known solos are mushy, and the fact that he’s ever Boomer Dad’s favorite guitarist makes me want to dislike him, but (a) a lot of his solos *aren’t* mushy, and the one in “Money” is unfuckwithable; and (b) he was a big and important advocate for the teenaged genius Kate Bush.

Re: Album: Dark Side of the Moon

85 by zorg
Re:Syd
Everybody today seems to think that "psych" is just like dark experimental raga grooves....but it was more a 50/50 split of between that, and high-ons goofing on ridiculous shit that seems hilarious only when high. This is why people hate hippies. Syd era PF was in no way unique in that way. The Byrd's "Mister Spaceman?" Get a job you fucking long-hairs. Eight Miles High? Far out man. This is part of why I don't like the Rock-Opera stuff like Tommy and The Wall...it was like the goofy music hall stuff coming back in vogue.

Re: Album: Dark Side of the Moon

90 by tallchris
enframed wrote: Mon Feb 10, 2025 10:06 am
JohnAlbert wrote: Mon Feb 10, 2025 6:08 am rock music being produced by Gen Z. Prog and Jazz fusion are in a major renaissance right now.
Curious what are some of these bands?
Not sure who John is thinking of but Goose definitely hit some of that in a jam band perspective, and the dumb looking/sounding bass and guitar help with the smooth fusion thing:

Band: www.bracketsseattle.bandcamp.com
Old band: www.burnpermits.bandcamp.com
Older band: www.policeteeth.bandcamp.com
Post Reply

Return to “Crap/Not Crap”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests