Hello Vinyl enthusiasts,
My name is David and I am an audiophile....
I worked at a HiFi shop for a almost 2 years right before I came back to New York and started working at Electro-Harmonix. We were not a Well Tempered dealer... only a Music Hall dealer so I have tried and set-up all of their models. I hope my insight helps.
Currently I'm running a Well Tempered Turntable with a $100 AT cart (440 ml I think). I bought this used for $600 at the shop I worked at, I got it at 'used cost'. These 'tables run about $1000 - $1500 on the used market and a new one will run you $3500. They also make an entry level 'table called the Record Player at about $1500 new. I highly recommend Well Tempered as they will track any shitty or warped records, eliminating most surface noise and are the most musical and tonally accurate 'tables I have ever heard. It will be the LAST 'table I ever buy. the older the model the cheaper they are. The guys at Well Tempered Lab will sell parts and upgrades directly. Oh yeah and there are no parts that can wear out!
http://www.welltemperedlab.com/
I sold my Rega Planar 3 because they run 1% too fast and it was driving me crazy. working at a hifi shop I had the opportunity for an even swap. I sold the Rega to a friend and they will be modifying the pulley to correct the speed. This is common amongst Rega 'Tables... even the new ones.
I originally had a Music Hall MMF 2. I had this for about 3 years and sold it to my best bud so I could get the Rega. he has been using it for about 4 years and it is now just starting to break down. It needs a new motor and bearing thrust plate. At $299 I would say this 'table doesn't owe us a dime.
A good starting point. I would say their $500 'table the MMF5 is a waste of time. once you've gone over the $500 hump you should be looking a a better brand.
other good 'tables I've liked:
Basis 1400
Progressive engineering "The Turntable"
and I actually love the old AR XA 'tables... they are fun and cheap. parts are a little hard to find though.
Good Luck,