Premier Rock Forum

I support Israel because Jews seem to be less fanatic and non-proselitist.

Fundamentalists have nothing to offer but religious fanaticism that is spreading quickly.

Unfortunately in our society we have to deal with mindless religious fanaticism. That's more than enough.

Having said that, what's going on in our society is not a Judeo-Christian vs. Islamic conflict.
The real conflit is between Scientific Enlightenment vs. Religious Thinking.

We all know that if Iran nukes Israel, the nuclear fallout will stop at the european border and turn around.. maybe poison turkey or egypt, but not us good neutral european fellas.

242sumner wrote:I support Israel because Jews are less fanatic and non-proselitist.

Muslims have nothing to offer but religious fanaticism and hatred that is spreading like a cancer.

Surely you jest. You are being facetious, right? Tell me you are. Please.

'Israel uses nuclear weapons in the same way the US does...as part of a mutually-assured-destruction deterrence system. Such a system depends on the assumption that no player is willing to commit suicide.

The Iranian government, on the other hand, is in the active business of providing weaponry to those who make a virtue of suicide attacks. They can't be trusted with nuclear weapons because of their current and recent past actions and statements. '

Whose destruction is mutually assured? No one else has any nukes or any kind of military presence near what Israel has (never mind that Israel went about getting nukes in much the same way that Iran is, just with better, more powerful friends). Under the current circumstances it sounds like dominance rather than some kind of balancing act.

Meanwhile, suicide bombers are wholly different than using the nuke as a nation. If the concern is allowing a suitcase bomb to be manufactured, there is little in the way of evidence that suggests that any of Israel's enemies have a sliver of the technology to produce something of the sort. That is alarmist rot.

I have no doubt that Iran wants the nuke. I have serious doubts that they would use it preemptively or aggressively. They have exactly zero history of using a comparable weapon in such a way. In fact, only the US does and only a handful of countries, one being Israel, has been as clandestine about getting the nuke.

I understand Israel's concern, which isn't the same thing as saying I agree. I don't see this as a tier one concern. Then again, I tend to find the bluster of the Iranian leadership to be much worse than its bite. If you really think that using the nuke is the same thing as supporting destabilizing suicide bombers, then I just don't know what.

Anyway, trying to get us to believe that Iran is going to attack Europe is preposterous. Rank stirring of the pot for obvious propagandistic reasons.

Dr. O' Nothing wrote:
Surely you jest. You are being facetious, right? Tell me you are. Please.

A fundamentalist Christian, Jew or Muslim are lack of brightness associated with improper education. They are ultimately victims of Organized Religions.

Christian and Muslims fundamentalist groups are violent. Their fundamentalism results in acts of violence. All form of violence.

Jewish fundamentalism is merely theoretical. Besides, they dont try to impose their faith on others.

You support Israel even though you know the kind of shit they do to the Palestinians?

They want the Jewish state of Israel wiped off the map.
The Iranian President said It very frankly.

242sumner wrote:

Dr. O' Nothing wrote:

242sumner wrote:I support Israel because Jews are less fanatic and non-proselitist.

Muslims have nothing to offer but religious fanaticism and hatred that is spreading like a cancer.

Surely you jest. You are being facetious, right? Tell me you are. Please.

A fundamentalist Christian, Jew or Muslim are lack of brightness associated with improper education. They are ultimately victims of Organized Religions.

Christian and Muslims fundamentalist groups are violent. Their fundamentalism results in acts of violence. All form of violence.

Jewish fundamentalism is merely theoretical. Besides, they dont try to impose their faith on others.

There's quite a difference between a 'fundamentalist' and your standard practicing Muslim.

Hell, i've even known a few who weren't terrorists...geez.

Not all Muslims, or even the majority, are violently inspired by their faith. Seriously, that is some fucked up shit you wrote in that original post, stereotyping all Muslims as religious fanatics.
I'm guessing you meant to specify 'fundamentalist' Muslims.

I'm assuming others here will address your other contentions re/non- violent jews, etc.

Rick Reuben wrote:

242sumner wrote:

242 sumner wrote:Muslims have nothing to offer but religious fanaticism and hatred that is spreading like a cancer.

I could say the same about Christians.(but not about Jews)

242sumner wrote:

Rick Reuben wrote:

242sumner wrote:

242 sumner wrote:Muslims have nothing to offer but religious fanaticism and hatred that is spreading like a cancer.

Yeah! And I could say the same about Christians.(but not about Jews)

Before you venerate the israeli government, take a good long look at the things they've done.

Their government wants nothing more than to see the Palestinians suffer.