houseboat wrote:The entire genre can be justified by the ten movies Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers made together, Top Hat most particularly.
The cinematography and choreography in any given Busby Berkely film is also Not Crap.
So, musicals from the sort of Golden Age of Hollywood are NOT CRAP to a degree that, I think, saves the genre from mass dismissal.
High waffles for any musical made after about 1955.
(and what about Bollywood?)
I've only seen a few of these and it was a while ago, and I'm sure their fine. My point wasn't that their aren't any good musicals, just that they are worse off for the characters break off into song every few minutes.
On a related note, I recently watched the old Christopher Lee
Wicker Man. There is a fair amount of singing in this, but it didn't bother me as much as a normal musical did. (It was still pretty crappy for other reasons).
That the music numbers didn't bother me was puzzling. Now I think this was OK because the only people who were singing were the batshit crazy people on the island. The straight cop, and presumably the rest of the world doesn't sing their way out of problems. And when they're singing the straight cop looks at them like, what the fuck?
The music isn't part of the world as a whole. So, it's not a musical.
This doesn't have a whole lot to do with the subject, just thought it was curious.