What do you think about Artificial Intelligence?

CRAP
Total votes: 56 (88%)
NOT CRAP
Total votes: 8 (13%)
Total votes: 64

Re: Thing: Artificial Intelligence

17
A friend who works in tech introduced me to OpenAI a few weeks ago and (helpfully) talked me through the context / industry shop talk around its development and where it's going w/ the Bing vs Bard war.

After playing around with ChatGBT for a few hours I felt like I did when I first had access to the Internet - that this technology was a radical game changer, like a sliver of the near-future had accidentally ended up on my friend's phone.

The shock and awe has worn down a bit since I've played around with it and it's been interesting to see that it's still confident even when I know it's factually wrong (I went round in circles about Geordie Walker's ES-295, which it didn't know about) and that it does have moral lines it won't cross (asking for help is always a positive sign of strength, no ifs, no buts). But I can see that once you link an upgraded version to the Internet w/ real time updates, then it'll be cooking straight away.

I'm quietly convinced that very quickly AI will do to the white collar, office-based knowledge economy and the corporate creatives what the industrial revolution did to the agrarian economy. And OpenAI are very clear that a low participation, max efficiency economy is a likely consequence of their vision, with most of the plebs like us left dependent on UBI.

IMO the key issue limiting the scope of this societal upheaval (at least in the short term) is how we manifest this supra-human knowledge into action and that's where human competence and confidence has a key role for the foreseeable. (E.G.: we now all have a tool that talks us through how to fix a plumbing problem in real time but we might not have the tools / strength / contextual knowledge / etc... to actually fix the problem ourselves.)

I'm more convinced by Thoreau / Kaczynski / Ellul than say, Lovelock's Novecene, but I'm so desperate for anything to disrupt our apathy and stagnation that I'll take what I can get.

Re: Thing: Artificial Intelligence

19
ChatGPT is (currently) about as useful as oblique strategies: maybe a good way to stir up thought but then you spend almost equal time scrutinizing, expanding, and editing ideas. Sure, high school kids will probably get away with using it to write long papers, but maybe quota-based 'learning' methods like assigning X-number paged papers is the thing that needs to be reevaluated.

AI overall is a massive thing to sum up: some amazing potential and some disastrous. I too worry about the monitoring and policing potential of it.

Re: Thing: Artificial Intelligence

20
penningtron wrote: ChatGPT is (currently) about as useful as oblique strategies: maybe a good way to stir up thought but then you spend almost equal time scrutinizing, expanding, and editing ideas.
I don't know. I have no experience with it and probably lack the chops or inclination to use it, but my super-brain college-age nephew, who is into coding on the side, seemed to think it could spit out very individualised answers to coding questions, like "how would I go about coding this or that specfic thing". If an intelligent search engine was a hugely useful tool, then surely something that combines that with highly specialised, nearly complete seeds from which to start more complex tasks, almost serving like individualised tutorials (if not fully realised solutions), must be more than "what would your grandmother change on this tune? do that!" or whatever. I am now old and don't move in that space and am unable to evaluate the relevancy or (real, even positive) power of these things moving forward based on personal experience. I would honestly imagine most of us are. It's easy for me to focus on the considerable negatives as a result, and the meta/political side of it, where I feel more informed or wise based on past observation. I would like to hear more from people using it in concrete ways that go beyond spitting out expository text.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: twelvepoint and 3 guests