Premier Rock Forum

Goat obviously but I love Liar.

I was pretty disappointed when Down came out and stopped paying attention to them.

I've always kinda listened to Goat/Liar like one album.
But it's Liar if I have to choose from those two.

I listen to Shot occasionally because I have a weird EMI advanced cassette copy.

Haha that press blurb is so lame it's kinda awesome and makes me wonder if it's a sly joke by the band?

That said, Thumper and Thumbscrews totally slay.

They're all good enough that it came down to the one with my favorite song rather than trying to discern a best overall. They're too close, at least between Goat, Liar and Down.

Anyway, I picked Down, because Horse. Strong showing from Zachariah, Nub and Mouth Breather.

I actually skip The Art of Self Defense more than anything.

Goat has just a little more variety and sonically has more breathing space than Liar, which I can at times find a little too unrelenting to get through in one sitting. Both fantastic records though.

Then it's Shot, (excellent first half but meanders a bit at the end, also sounds great, IMHO) Down, (meh) Head (dated Ugly-American-Overkill vibe that they evolved past quickly) and the rest.

jason from volo wrote: Mon Jun 07, 2021 4:51 pm

Dave N. wrote: Mon Jun 07, 2021 4:34 pm He counts to 12. The phrase is 12 beats long, so he counts to 12 twice during the intro.

Counting to 12 isn't my problem... at least I think I can still do that.

My problem is that, for the life of me, I cannot figure out where the damn downbeat is, and therefore when to start counting to 12.

C’mon, man. It’s child’s play.

Dave N. wrote: Sat Jun 12, 2021 10:44 pm

jason from volo wrote: Mon Jun 07, 2021 4:51 pm

Dave N. wrote: Mon Jun 07, 2021 4:34 pm He counts to 12. The phrase is 12 beats long, so he counts to 12 twice during the intro.

Counting to 12 isn't my problem... at least I think I can still do that.

My problem is that, for the life of me, I cannot figure out where the damn downbeat is, and therefore when to start counting to 12.

C’mon, man. It’s child’s play.

BRB, selling all my gear...

Goat. That said, I've played it so much over the years that I'm more likely to put on Liar, Head or even Down and Shot nowadays; I need to give Goat a few more years on the bench before I can go back to rocking it...

Chrome 7" and Pure

Real Sophie's Choice kind of question.

Next you're going to be asking me about my favorite Effigies album. LOL

Check this out, it never gets old.


Nice Foetus shirt.

Goat and Liar are pretty much neck and neck for me, but “Boilermaker” might be the best album opener ever.

So yeah, that one.