Page 2 of 5

Worst Neil Young Song

Posted: Wed Aug 03, 2005 8:31 pm
by ing curtis_Archive
a man needs a maid for sure

Worst Neil Young Song

Posted: Wed Aug 03, 2005 8:52 pm
by hench_Archive
BadComrade wrote:Uh, how about anything on TRANS?


you've gotta be kiddin me. trans is awesome. i've got 2 copies.


let's roll is weak. the way flaneur feels about 'sugar mountain' is the way i feel about 'heart of gold.' it's been so overplayed that it's lost its meaning...

Worst Neil Young Song

Posted: Wed Aug 03, 2005 8:55 pm
by tmidgett_Archive
hench wrote:let's roll is weak. the way flaneur feels about 'sugar mountain' is the way i feel about 'heart of gold.' it's been so overplayed that it's lost its meaning...


ok, so let's agree that 'let's roll' is the worst neil song ever

'heart of gold' is great. it's great for many reasons, but the drumming alone would make it great.

i like 'a man needs a maid' a lot. i think he's lettin' it all hang out, in a good way.

Worst Neil Young Song

Posted: Wed Aug 03, 2005 9:38 pm
by Ike_Archive
tmidgett done wrote: i like 'a man needs a maid' a lot. i think he's lettin' it all hang out, in a good way.

Someone said a very similar thing to me about this song a while back--he's ripping through the song, vocals sound great, just gettin' it done.

I just simply cannot see it. My wife doesn't like it for the abject silliness of the lyrics. But this is a big part of his deal, particularly in the early 70's. You know "I dreamed I saw the sliver spaceships flying" that type of thing. I really like most of that stuff.

I will just agree to disagree!

Mayfair and Tmidgett, you are fine folks!

Ike[/quote]

Worst Neil Young Song

Posted: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:32 am
by oucheh_Archive
Without question "let's roll"

Maybe all of "Greendale."

What was the mid-eighties country record? "Old Times" or some bullshit?
Those songs were atrocious.

-Jeremy

Worst Neil Young Song

Posted: Thu Aug 04, 2005 10:01 am
by Fancy Pants_Archive
Brett Eugene Ralph wrote:Ronnie Van Zant, it turns out, was right. As usual.


I've loved Neil Young for almost 20 years. I've loved Skynyrd and especially Ronnie Van Zant almost as long. I used to think they hated each other so you can imagine my surprise when I was watching a Skynyrd documentary a few years ago and saw Ronnie on stage wearing a Neil Young "Tonight's the Night" t-shirt. I have since learned that they had a great mutual respect and admiration for one another.

So, you are correct - as usual, Ronnie was right.

Worst Neil Young Song

Posted: Thu Aug 04, 2005 10:18 am
by Bradley R Weissenberger_Archive
Fancy Pants wrote:I was watching a Skynyrd documentary a few years ago and saw Ronnie on stage wearing a Neil Young "Tonight's the Night" t-shirt. I have since learned that they had a great mutual respect and admiration for one another.

More information here.

And "Southern Man" is a great song.

Worst Neil Young Song

Posted: Thu Aug 04, 2005 10:55 am
by Angus Jung
The article Brad links doesn't mention it, but I have heard that Ronnie Van Zandt was buried in that "Tonight's The Night" T-shirt.

Worst Neil Young Song

Posted: Thu Aug 04, 2005 11:19 am
by wes9_Archive
oucheh wrote:Without question "let's roll"

Maybe all of "Greendale."

What was the mid-eighties country record? "Old Times" or some bullshit?
Those songs were atrocious.

-Jeremy


"Comes a Time," and yes, it is not very good at all.

Worst Neil Young Song

Posted: Thu Aug 04, 2005 11:31 am
by stevenstillborn_Archive
I've never really been a fan of "Heart of Gold," but if the question is the absolute worst Neil Young song, then the answer if "Old King" of Harvest Moon.