rzs wrote:Arson Smith wrote:rzs wrote:"Boulevard of Broken Dreams" by Greenday...
Oh shit yes.
I haven't thought of this one in a while (fortunately), but I can recall even the very very first time a radio played it at me... my first thought was that perhaps it was intentionally cut & pasted together from all the crappiest rock-n-roll lyrics cliches ever... but it wasn't a joke song (right?) so there is really no excuse for these lyrics THAT TRY SO HARD TO SAY NOTHING
- walking a "lonely road"
- road/street/boulevard/whatever of (broken) dreams
- personification of 'shadow' and 'city' (shadow walks, city sleeps)
- being 'on the border line' of something or another
blech.
I know...It is so cliched that the first time I heard it, I couldn't believe my ears.
You can intuit many of the lyrics word for word prior to when they are sung because they are pre-figured in the cliched line before. The cliches you touched on are burned into our brains from years of listening to other songs with horrible lyrics.
YES - thank you for putting that so succinctly - the observation was in my brain, but I didn't know how to get it out...
I guess the only other thing to take into account is that things like "rock cliches" are only such painful cliches to us that have a larger body of experience than say pre-teens who are just now getting into "rock bands" (such generic use of 'rock', I know).
Not that long ago I did take my girlfriend to go see Green Day here in St. Louis... the venue (Savvis hockey rink) was completely overrun with 13-14 year olds (and their attendant parents/chaperones) with the ratio probably being 2/3 female to 1/3 male.
I was maybe a little bit surprised at how many of the audience where in that age range... and then it all kind of came together in my head. This Green Day band, they are geniuses, in that they have long ago stopped writing songs for dudes their own age. I think the 'Boulevard Of Broken Dreams' song is engineered precisely to appeal to the young crowd, because they don't have enough history in them to been worn out on the cliches.
People die everyday, and people are born every day. I guess to be a successfully
commercial artist, you take this into account and don't worry about a certain fanbase that is growing with you and knows its past...
I guess what I'm trying to say is that if you write to a 14-year old angst level, then congratulations, because every single day there are plenty of kids who are just turning 14.
(and somehow this brings me back to thinking of this hoo-ha about the claim that NickelBack is ripping off fans by releasing new songs that sound just like their previous ones... but this would be based on the assumption that anybody has the attention-span to follow NickelBack's career/'journey as artists'/whatever... I think NickelBack themselves know, and are banking on the fact, that whoever bought their album from 2003 can't be bothered to buy their latest album, and conversely a new fan buying the latest can't be arsed to buy up the back-catalog... I think they are banking on the fact that they will appeal to no-attention-span-having peoples, and they can just retread all they want - this little blip of media attention will pass and they can still laugh all the way to the banc...)