I thought I'd pop my cherry on this thread.
Hi.
I use pedals. I make them myself. They look like this:
I wanted to build my ideal distortion, so I spent some time building a bunch of different circuits. I ended up sticking with ways to overdrive my amp and add a ring modulated tone. From right to left, the switches are for a sustain, an orange sqeezer, a green ringer, and a 60 dB boost (useless at full throttle, but it makes it clear I'm not fucking around). Each of these has been modded to some extent, optimized for my guitar and amp.
This is a copy of a Tychobrae Octavia, not intentionally modded. Intentionally? I'm pretty sure I fucked it up somehow when I made it because it doesn't sound like something someone would make and market. But it functions quie well and I like it. It's a weird circuit, regardless, and I'm sure assembled right it would sound equally interesting.
I buy the boxes at the flea market. Obviously.
These 2 boxes cover all of my live musical needs currently.