149
by tmidgett_Archive
bumble wrote:This Naked Mind for a summary.(this'll be too long. i know b/c i already wrote it. sorry in advance.)I just read that book. I have a family member who is in need and deeply skeptical of AA, so I figured it was worth a shot.Liked some things about it. The focus on alcohol. The (true!) notion that you don't have to hit rock bottom. Some people can drop it like a rock, often once they have sufficient knowledge of how alcohol works. How addictive it can be. How incrementally damaging and insidious it is. How easy it is for it to fuck up your life before you pick up on what is happening. How invasively it is pushed on literally everyone in Western culture at every waking moment.This book provides much of that baseline info. Most of the data and science in the book is presented in a useful way, to people who don't know any of it yet, especially. Alcohol's effect on the brain, in particular--just fucked up and underrecognized. But there are some really key mistakes/oversights. She gives short shrift to genetic predisposition to alcoholism--well-established as a real thing at this point. I would suggest Beyond the Influence as a much better source on that front (better book in general). And she falsely claims (twice) that teen drinking is on the rise, that it's never been more prevalent. Just not true at all. It's been on a steep decline since the early 80s.And the book glides over the tremendous difficulty some people have getting and staying sober. If you've hit it even moderately hard for any kind of while, it might be months before you are at physical or mental equilibrium. Odds are that recovery time will be rocky. Often not something you can read about in a book and understand. Better than having continued a drinking life, but it may not feel like it a lot of the time--and an alcohol-addled brain encourages anyone in recovery to question the wisdom of having stopped, often long after the initial drying-out.To advocate making that trek w/o organized support...I just have a problem with it, when it's put forth as if it's The Answer. I think it's a bit pat.That said, I know the basic method outlined in the book works for some people. It's essentially what worked for me. But I had sixteen years of living with an alcoholic, watching him get sober, and going to AA meetings with him, before I even started drinking in earnest. Anyway, maybe This Naked Mind is about 25% problems and the rest is pretty good. Better than most "here's the new special way we figured out to quit drinking" things. Good enough to send to someone who thinks 12-step is bullshit and hope she reads it. Whatever gets a person quit when they need to quit is all right.