Display posts from previous
Sort by

Metallica.

CRAP
Total votes: 82 (62%)
NOT CRAP
Total votes: 50 (38%)
Total votes: 132

Band: Metallica

151 by Marsupialized_Archive
Garage days is not getting the respect it deserves here

Garage days is a supreme record, the killing joke cover alone is something I can't imagine someone ever having a problem with, it's really great
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WivZu4-Y61Y
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6alceembkVk&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g74J0F92G2s&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZV9pu9b3wIk&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OxbTwwluACM&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g74J0F92G2s&feature=related
Rick Reuben wrote:Marsupialized reminds me of freedom

Band: Metallica

153 by Antero_Archive
CRAP.

Waffles for Cliff Burton's chops, their obvious influence, and because I can understand how they would have been a damn good live act in the early days...

...but seriously, crap. Crappy songwriting, consistently embarrassing lyrics, boring guitar solos, lousy drumming, singing that gets downright cringeworthy, melody pretty much absent.

I guess I agree with miseryandthesun, is what it is.
http://www.myspace.com/leopoldandloebchicago

Linus Van Pelt wrote:I subscribe to neither prong of your false dichotomy.

Band: Metallica

154 by RWD_Archive


I can confirm that Metallica's version of The wait is indeed horrible. Contary to public belief they were not big fans of the band - it was suggested to them to cover for hipness sakes. Master of puppets is possibly the best metal album ever. Still crap though from the black album onwards.

Band: Metallica

155 by BClark_Archive
Marsupialized wrote:Garage days is not getting the respect it deserves here


that whiskey in a jar cover was cool, but not as cool as the jerry garcia version. the discharge cover is not bad.

any word as to how metallica gets mostly crap votes, megadeth mostly not crap votes, and yet metallica did better than megadeth in their thunderdome?
http://www.soundclick.com/hanabimusic (band)
http://www.myspace.com/iambls (i make beats for that dude)

Band: Metallica

156 by lemur68_Archive
BClark wrote:
Marsupialized wrote:Garage days is not getting the respect it deserves here


that whiskey in a jar cover was cool, but not as cool as the jerry garcia version. the discharge cover is not bad.


He was talking about

Image


not

Image
tocharian wrote:Cheese fries vs nonexistence. Duh.

Band: Metallica

158 by Marsupialized_Archive
RWD wrote:


I can confirm that Metallica's version of The wait is indeed horrible. Contary to public belief they were not big fans of the band - it was suggested to them to cover for hipness sakes. Master of puppets is possibly the best metal album ever. Still crap though from the black album onwards.


Their version of the wait is a real good thrash track, one of the best there is.

Hipness sakes? How hip was Killing Joke at the time?
NOT AT ALL, dude. The opposite of hip, they were doing foofy goth disco at the time.
I read the story, everything on garage days was off the only mix tape (that Kirk made) they had to listen to on an entire European tour. They knew the songs inside and out by the end of the tour and just went in and did them with Jason to get him used to recording with the band.
Rick Reuben wrote:Marsupialized reminds me of freedom

Band: Metallica

159 by emmanuelle cunt_Archive
Marsupialized wrote:
RWD wrote:


I can confirm that Metallica's version of The wait is indeed horrible. Contary to public belief they were not big fans of the band - it was suggested to them to cover for hipness sakes. Master of puppets is possibly the best metal album ever. Still crap though from the black album onwards.


Their version of the wait is a real good thrash track, one of the best there is.

Hipness sakes? How hip was Killing Joke at the time?
NOT AT ALL, dude. The opposite of hip, they were doing foofy goth disco at the time.
I read the story, everything on garage days was off the only mix tape (that Kirk made) they had to listen to on an entire European tour. They knew the songs inside and out by the end of the tour and just went in and did them with Jason to get him used to recording with the band.



I wonder if this is true. I mean, James Hatfield is not able to get the fucking Smells Like Teen Spirit riff right, while Lars fucks the bit of drumming at the beginning.

Band: Metallica

160 by RWD_Archive
Marsupialized wrote:
RWD wrote:


I can confirm that Metallica's version of The wait is indeed horrible. Contary to public belief they were not big fans of the band - it was suggested to them to cover for hipness sakes. Master of puppets is possibly the best metal album ever. Still crap though from the black album onwards.


Their version of the wait is a real good thrash track, one of the best there is.

Hipness sakes? How hip was Killing Joke at the time?
NOT AT ALL, dude. The opposite of hip, they were doing foofy goth disco at the time.
I read the story, everything on garage days was off the only mix tape (that Kirk made) they had to listen to on an entire European tour. They knew the songs inside and out by the end of the tour and just went in and did them with Jason to get him used to recording with the band.


I stand corrected. Their cover of this song was not pre-ordained to gain respect among the indie community, however, I still think the song loses all its intensity with that version. The groove is lost and the vocals sound like they're sung under water. Then of course there's the obligatory solo. KJ don't have a single solo on any of their songs - Metallica obviously felt that the song needed something snappy in the middle...
Post Reply

Return to “Crap / Not Crap”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests