There’s such a subjective quality to sound. What sounds good to one person doesn’t to another. I think most of us here like things that sound, for lack of a better term, un-fucked-with, a sound which Albini and other have championed with their work.
Go elsewhere, like, I don’t know, radioland or Mtv—wherever money is really—and you’ll probably get a different take on how a rock band should sound.
A book by somebody from the former camp wouldn’t be bad. I know the old Tape-Op book, which is just a compilation of interviews from the magazine’s first few years, served me really well—probably the best “book for a recording a rock band” I ever read.
You can get it here still:
http://www.tapeop.com/shop/tapeopbook.html