vote

David Wm. Sims
Total votes: 19 (59%)
Tracy Pew
Total votes: 13 (41%)
Total votes: 32

Bassists: David Wm. Sims vs Tracy Pew

31
Ace wrote:
SecondEdition wrote:If you didn't get it yet, I think "Monkey Trick" is pretty much the worst song on Goat


:shock:

Listen to the version on 'Gong' then try telling me it's not up there with the best stuff they ever did.


I don't have Gong.

Look, I can't account for taste. I just know that I think every other song on Goat is better. I didn't say it was a bad song, for christsakes...

and Pew really is a better bassist. Just saying.
Life...life...I know it's got its ups and downs.

Groucho Marx wrote:Politics is the art of looking for trouble, finding it, misdiagnosing it and then misapplying the wrong remedies.

Bassists: David Wm. Sims vs Tracy Pew

32
SecondEdition wrote:
Ace wrote:
SecondEdition wrote:If you didn't get it yet, I think "Monkey Trick" is pretty much the worst song on Goat


:shock:

Listen to the version on 'Gong' then try telling me it's not up there with the best stuff they ever did.


I don't have Gong.

Look, I can't account for taste. I just know that I think every other song on Goat is better. I didn't say it was a bad song, for christsakes...

and Pew really is a better bassist. Just saying.


That's true. I voted for him. I never liked Sims that much.


BUT, I am going to PM you with the sendspace for 'Gong' shortly. You really should hear it.
Well, that's just, like, your opinion, man.

Bassists: David Wm. Sims vs Tracy Pew

33
Ace wrote:
SecondEdition wrote:
Ace wrote:
SecondEdition wrote:If you didn't get it yet, I think "Monkey Trick" is pretty much the worst song on Goat


:shock:

Listen to the version on 'Gong' then try telling me it's not up there with the best stuff they ever did.


I don't have Gong.

Look, I can't account for taste. I just know that I think every other song on Goat is better. I didn't say it was a bad song, for christsakes...

and Pew really is a better bassist. Just saying.


That's true. I voted for him. I never liked Sims that much.


BUT, I am going to PM you with the sendspace for 'Gong' shortly. You really should hear it.


Cool beans. What is it, live?
Life...life...I know it's got its ups and downs.

Groucho Marx wrote:Politics is the art of looking for trouble, finding it, misdiagnosing it and then misapplying the wrong remedies.

Bassists: David Wm. Sims vs Tracy Pew

34
SecondEdition wrote:
Ace wrote:
SecondEdition wrote:
Ace wrote:
SecondEdition wrote:If you didn't get it yet, I think "Monkey Trick" is pretty much the worst song on Goat


:shock:

Listen to the version on 'Gong' then try telling me it's not up there with the best stuff they ever did.


I don't have Gong.

Look, I can't account for taste. I just know that I think every other song on Goat is better. I didn't say it was a bad song, for christsakes...

and Pew really is a better bassist. Just saying.


That's true. I voted for him. I never liked Sims that much.


BUT, I am going to PM you with the sendspace for 'Gong' shortly. You really should hear it.


Cool beans. What is it, live?


Their very last show
Well, that's just, like, your opinion, man.

Bassists: David Wm. Sims vs Tracy Pew

37
timpickens wrote:If Monkey Trick isn't the worst track on Goat, then which one is?

It's hard for me to decide.


See, that's the beauty of 'Goat' - there IS no worst song. maybe you like certain songs better than others at different times, but it's comforting when you listen to it to think that all the songs are fantastic.
Well, that's just, like, your opinion, man.

Bassists: David Wm. Sims vs Tracy Pew

39
scott wrote:
Ace wrote:See, that's the beauty of 'Goat' - there IS no worst song.


The only way that's possible is if every song is exactly identically great, with no song being better than any other in any way. Is that realistic, or are some songs probably even slightly better than others?


It's more like, when you're listening to the album you'll think one song is the worst, but it will immediately change upon another listen, or maybe even during the same spin. I can have one favorite, but the values of the songs are fluid.

Never mind, my love for goat is making me type funny words. back to Pew v. Sims.
Well, that's just, like, your opinion, man.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest