rayj wrote:Bad news for me.
I e-mailed Mr. Tomkins concerning downloads of Sutcliffe Jugend material...especially the 'We Spit On Their Graves' stuff. Here's the reply:
Hi Ray
Thanks for your honesty regards the downloading of "We Spit On Their Graves".
WSOTG is a difficult issue. Especially regarding genuine fans like yourself. People want to hear it, but there are only a handfull of original legitimate copies around. The prices some people have paid for the vinyl bootleg have been surprising to say the least. Against this of course are the matters of artistic and mechanical control.
We do intend to reissue WSOTG in it's complete form in the not too distant future. So clearly downloads may cause a problem at some stage.
However, while I cannot condone the downloading of our music, I fully understand people's need to hear difficult to find releases. All very easy to do in a world where it is obtainable free at the touch of a button.
Due to file sharing program's such as Soulseek, downloads are an inevitable inconvinience for artists. I think it becomes more of a problem when downloads are made available on the internet through forum's, blogs or personal download site's.
If I could put a stop to people downloading Sutcliffe Jugend material tomorrow, I would.
This will never happen.
While not giving you a straight reply, I hope this goes some way to answering your question, which I think is a personal issue at the end of the day. Either you are comfortable doing it, or you are not . . .
Whatever your decision I would ask that you do not share it with anyone else.
regards
Kevin
In return, I offered to pay him for the privilege of listening to these files, or to prepay for an order of the upcoming reissue. I'm still waiting to hear back on that...
This is a case where I'm
definitely wanting to comply with the artist's wishes. However, I will never be able to afford access to the originals...so, if Mr. Tomkins doesn't reply relatively soon, I'm left with no choice but to delete these wonderful files. Which I haven't listened to yet.
Fucking hell.
Wow. Way to go, making me look like a dick.
I love Sutcliffe Jugend. I really do. I heard about them from someone on this board, and went on a rampage getting what I could of theirs. Then I heard about the box set. Shit. Fuck. Piss. Violent overload. A friend of mine and a fellow SJ fan went searching, and believe it or not the next day he gave me a CD-R with the entire set. I mean, fuck, if that doesn't speak for just how much people want this set, nothing does. Figured I'd share it since it was THIS board which made me put some of my money on the table for Tompkins, and sorry folks, but I doubt anyone on this board has (and if they do, would they?) the nearly $500 to shell out for the OOP set.
If it was reissued tomorrow, I'd buy it. I'd even post pictures of my journey to a record store that had it. But until then, I do want to hear it, and with no disrespect to Mr. Tompkins, yeah, I'm going to listen to it and love it. But if he is adamantly against sharing it, I'm won't do it any longer. I think the sendspace link is dead by now anyways.
Before this turns into another download debate or whatever, I will say I admire your courage for emailing Mr. Tompkins about illegally(?) downloading his set. You have a much bigger (and obviously more overwhelming) conscience than I do. I wonder how much he may "charge" you for downloading an OOP, sold out, low bit rate rip of a box set (with no .jpgs or even a .txt file). I'm still kind of shocked he actually gives a shit. By the same token, who knows how I'd feel in the same situation?
Anyone going to write to Stockhausen or Phil Spector?