Anthony Flack wrote: Thu Sep 12, 2024 4:47 pm
It must have seemed like a crazy idea to replace Tanya Donelly with a rank amateur, but crazy like a fox as it turned out.
Kelly is irreplaceable.
I’ve seen the Breeders with another rhythm section. It wasn’t better but it was about as great, just different.
Kelly’s zero vibrato, all the same weight guitar bits would sound very different in the hands of any normal guitar player. A normal player would do a bunch of guitarist shit to the parts and ruin them.
I’ve heard Kim talk about bass playing and her aversion to anything tricky in it. I don’t know if she taught or asked Kelly to play the way she does, but it’s perfect, purpose built for the band.