Rodabod wrote:I love the comments people have a left on that page:
"This song really touched me and made me think about the war and all the lives that have been killed. That is sad that he said he will never live her and he sighned up to go to the war. Wow this is so sad. They just made me think about all the familys that lose a soilder :cry: "
WOW. It really touched me too. Oh no, wait a second, no, it actually made me feel nauseous having to endure the corny film scenes.
I went and looked for that video on iFilm.
Before I was able to view the video on iFilm, I had to sit through an Army recruiting advertisement. In the ad, a young black man tells his mother that he's "found someone to pay for college", and that "it's time for him to be a man". The GoArmy.com website address is featured prominently in the ad.
There's your nausea, Rodabod.
In light of the massive war propaganda to which people are subjected, I'd be very willing to give Green Day, the writer and director of this video, the young actors, MTV, and all of the young fans who expressed their emotions ("all the lives that have been killed") on that website a complete pass, if only because they used their forum to say no.
But I actually like that video, at least as far as music videos go, I guess. Are the edits a little jarring? Sure. Is the acting a little wooden? Yes. But it's pretty well done, and the story caught me off guard. Moreover, I like that song, I like Green Day, and I like the fact that they wrote an entire record that tells George Bush to fuck off -- and that their message is resonating, at least to some degree.
Maybe my expectations are diminished for popular culture, but you could do a whole lot worse than this Green Day video.
Salut, Rodabod! I know that you do not like this video. Wtf, she is music video! What is really to like? But I think this video, she is maybe pretty good in both concept and execution.