Book Talk
Posted: Sat Jan 27, 2007 12:10 pm
So I got to the end of my mission to read every novel by John O'Hara in order. As an act, this was crap, with lots of waffles. It was interesting to see the development of his themes; for example, he works the same story around a couple of times before finally hitting it with 'From The Terrace'. As soon as that story is out the way (Pennsylvania, society, money, family history, sex), he quickly shifts to Broadway for the next novel. That was interesting.
Right now though, I've had to go back to the first O'Hara I read, a collection called 'The O'Hara Omnibus'. I'm skipping rereading 'Pal Joey', his Ring Lardner-ish baseball stories-told-through-letters (good, but not what I'm interested in right now) to 'Hope of Heaven', which will be followed by 'Sermons and Soda Water'. Both are short story collections, and already I'm back to where I love this guy's writing; he's a master of the short form.
The crapness was from the sheer relentlessness of hearing the same voice for so long - although it's a voice I love. And because the sore parts were laid very much bare. I should have broken it up with some other books but there wasn't much on my to-read pile which appealed.
I just read the C/NC on Henry Miller and tommydski put the case that Miller reveals an era and a society as it actually was. The same is true of O'Hara I think. He was absolutely relentless about Pennsylvania society, everyone in everything is from Gibbsville, PA, or somewhere near. Even the stories about Los Angeles involve main characters from PA. That's interesting, being so determined to so intimately describe a certain type. It was clearly his mission, and he succeeded. I know the way I think about that region will forever be burned by O'Hara's writing.
(I'll read something by someone else soon, I promise, if only so I can be more interesting in this thread!)
Right now though, I've had to go back to the first O'Hara I read, a collection called 'The O'Hara Omnibus'. I'm skipping rereading 'Pal Joey', his Ring Lardner-ish baseball stories-told-through-letters (good, but not what I'm interested in right now) to 'Hope of Heaven', which will be followed by 'Sermons and Soda Water'. Both are short story collections, and already I'm back to where I love this guy's writing; he's a master of the short form.
The crapness was from the sheer relentlessness of hearing the same voice for so long - although it's a voice I love. And because the sore parts were laid very much bare. I should have broken it up with some other books but there wasn't much on my to-read pile which appealed.
I just read the C/NC on Henry Miller and tommydski put the case that Miller reveals an era and a society as it actually was. The same is true of O'Hara I think. He was absolutely relentless about Pennsylvania society, everyone in everything is from Gibbsville, PA, or somewhere near. Even the stories about Los Angeles involve main characters from PA. That's interesting, being so determined to so intimately describe a certain type. It was clearly his mission, and he succeeded. I know the way I think about that region will forever be burned by O'Hara's writing.
(I'll read something by someone else soon, I promise, if only so I can be more interesting in this thread!)