Band: Harvey Milk

CRAP
Total votes: 2 (6%)
NOT CRAP
Total votes: 32 (94%)
Total votes: 34

Band: Harvey Milk

71
burun wrote:Holy shit were these guys a great show.

Seriously.

Go see them.

So much rock.

Their completely adorable drummer sold me some of their CD's, and seemed to be incredibly pleased that

a) I was buying them before they played
b) I was a girl buying their records
Kyle Spence. Great guy. Great drummer.

Band: Harvey Milk

72
Isn't it great when you discover a band's music and then you find not only have they made the one awesome record you're listening to but that they have a huge back catalogue that does not deviate from excellence once. That rarely happens.
It's even rarer that you get into them just in time for them to come and play your shitty little island for the first time ever and then get to see them twice.
And the demographic comment is right - it was a girl who got me into them too.
Rick Reuben wrote:We're all sensitive people
With so much love to give, understand me sugar
Since we got to be... Lets say, I love you

Band: Harvey Milk

73
Verbs and Nouns wrote:Suggestions for the best first record to get?


I know this has been replied to a couple of times already, but i think the album that works best as an introduction to every side of what they do would be 'Special Wishes'. Maybe the Singles compilation if Special Wishes was out of stock or something.

'Courtesy...' is surely their opus, but even as a huge fan i sometimes find it too much. I mean, it's just so stupidly heavy. The gravity of it makes me sad sometimes, especially if i listen to it all the way through too often.
'The Pleaser' has it's moments but doesn't really showcase what they're fully capable of in my opinion. 'My Love...' and 'Life...' are also good, but not quite in the same league i reckon.



For what it's worth, when i was spending obscene amounts of money at the merch table (for me and on behalf of 3 others), Lady Surfrider was having a hard time making a decision on what to purchase.

Creston Spiers: You okay there?
Lady Surfrider: Yeah i'm with him (gestures towards me, stuffing 4 double LPs, 3 teeshirts, 2 posters and 1 cd in to my bag).
CS: Oh, okay.
LS: Although i wouldn't mind one of my own.
CS: Get this one then (points at 'Special Wishes' cd). It's the best one.
LS: Oh okay then. But i'll have it on record please.
CS: Girls buying Harvey Milk vinyl?! Man, what next?
LS: Thanks.


Their show was brilliant by the way. And yeah, they really do need to wise up to this female fanbase they've got going on.
You're a shit DM and i want my pizza money back.

Band: Harvey Milk

74
Agreed.

"Harvey Milk For The Ladies" shirts. I hereby offer to design one for free though they already have the best shirt ever (E.T. smoking chong with a shirt on that reads NO WOMAN NO CRY)
Rick Reuben wrote:We're all sensitive people
With so much love to give, understand me sugar
Since we got to be... Lets say, I love you

Band: Harvey Milk

75
I listened to my first Harvey Milk song last night and immediately turned it off because I liked it so much and I didn't have the time to actively listen.

It was "Merlin is Magic"

I absolutely loved it

I hope the rest of their stuff is comparable.

I plan on listening to it on my drive to Jersey on Saturday
scott wrote:It was fun. We laughed, we cried, most of us shit ourselves as far as I know. What a world.

Band: Harvey Milk

76
fedaykin13 wrote:I listened to my first Harvey Milk song last night and immediately turned it off because I liked it so much and I didn't have the time to actively listen.

It was "Merlin is Magic"

I absolutely loved it

I hope the rest of their stuff is comparable.

I plan on listening to it on my drive to Jersey on Saturday


That's about my least favourite of their songs. Some of their stuff is comparable but I'd say it's not especially representative. I'm not saying that to put you off in any way, you should just be prepared for the remainder of their catalogue to be about 10x as good as you are expecting. And not what you are expecting.
Don't shun it. Fun it.

Band: Harvey Milk

77
"I'm excited to announce Southern Shelter Record(s) and our first (and only?) release, a 7" vinyl single by Harvey Milk frontman Creston Spiers! I brought the Southern Shelter Mobile Recording Unit to Creston's home in Athens recently and recorded two of his unreleased original songs. Side A is "Yesterday's Parade", written for the band A (who never made a release); it's backed with "The Time Has Come", written during Creston's time drumming for Producto. These songs are drastically different from Creston's Harvey Milk work. Both tracks have him backed only by acoustic 12-string (sitting on his couch!)"

http://southernshelter.com/2008/06/sout ... piers.html

It seems the seven-inch is sold out through Chunklet...but there's also this:

"Of course I have some free music to post in celebration. Creston played a happy hour Nuci's Space benefit at Caledonia (during which I realized he'd be perfect for the record I wanted to do). Leonard Cohen is his favorite artist, so we got all Cohen tunes, save for the last number."

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests