???

Sabbath
Total votes: 49 (61%)
Zeppelin
Total votes: 31 (39%)
Total votes: 80

Either-Or: Black Sabbath or Led Zeppelin?

2
SABBATH, for god's sake. I love them.

In this thread, I wrote:I honestly rate Led Zeppelin as a horrible, horrible band, and can't think of anything about them that doesn't make my stomach turn, except for Bonham's drumming sometimes.

Robert Plant (and Roger Daltrey for that matter, though the Who weren't nearly as awful as Zeppelin) really set the bar high for how damned irritating a singer can be. Led Zeppelin = endless bullshit guitar solos, proto-cock rock shrieking, tiresome and unexceptional "bluesy" garbage, and some of the worst lyrics to ever be bleated out. Seriously. Every song need not be about either fucking or Hobbits and other fantastical crap. I can't fathom people taking this band seriously, yet they do.


I stand by this assertion.
Last edited by placeholder_Archive on Mon Jan 23, 2006 4:57 pm, edited 2 times in total.
matthew wrote:His Life and his Death gives us LIFE.......supernatural life- which is His own life because he is God and Man. This is all straight Catholicism....no nuttiness or mystical crap here.

Either-Or: Black Sabbath or Led Zeppelin?

10
for dumbass rock music? sabbath.
for music w/ more than just riffs? zeppelin.

zeppelin used a keyboard and it didn't suck. see, "trampled underfoot" for details. for real kicks, look up the lyrics.

"sabbra cadabra," anyone? blech. thanks, rick wakeman. worse than "stairway..." anyday.

i like my rock music with as much balls as brains, both of these have more of one than the other. but zep has a better ratio, at least in my opinion.

zeppelin had a more solid output from beginning to end. sabbath got more than a little shakey even in the middle of their career. plus zep stopped. stopping is nice. trotting out 50+ yr olds to play hits they wrote at 20...not so hot.

anyways, when i'm feeling stupid? sabbath. when i'm feeling maudlin? zeppelin.
buy my guitar. now with pictures!

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests