Premier Rock Forum

Posted: **Sat Jan 13, 2007 5:55 pm**

is there a finer example of music production? please tell me if there is

Posted: **Sat Jan 13, 2007 6:10 pm**

Posted: **Sat Jan 13, 2007 6:21 pm**

so, SO, wrong pal... some great bands though

Posted: **Sat Jan 13, 2007 6:31 pm**

BadComrade wrote:He's wrong in the sense that the bands that have recorded at Electrical aren't really "produced", yeah.

Fuck! You're right.....

Posted: **Sat Jan 13, 2007 6:31 pm**

BadComrade wrote:He's wrong in the sense that the bands that have recorded at Electrical aren't really "produced", yeah.

idiot

Posted: **Sat Jan 13, 2007 6:38 pm**

Ya know, i've seen some pretty extreme and blatant examples of trolling--your typical "log in and post ridiculous sexist/racist/homophobic" crap, Being pro-Bush in a liberal forum, etc...but i have to give this new guy credit. Registering on the EA Forum and immediately extolling the virtues of Pink Floyd exhibits a sense of subtlety in trolling and an understanding of the audience being trolled that is far more sophisticated than your typical flame-junkie.

Salut! mw!

Posted: **Sat Jan 13, 2007 6:40 pm**

BadComrade wrote:Who's the "idiot"?

who is saying the albums "recorded at Electrical" aren't " really produced"?

i'm just stating a personal view.. and my view is pink floyd=perfection as far as production is concerned

discuss

Posted: **Sat Jan 13, 2007 6:49 pm**

DrAwkward wrote:Registering on the EA Forum and immediately extolling the virtues of Pink Floyd exhibits a sense of subtlety in trolling and an understanding of the audience being trolled that is far more sophisticated than your typical flame-junkie.

Check his/her "joined" date. Hardly immediate.

I much prefer Pink Floyd over Sonic Youth. Your values are not shared by everyone here, doc. Speaking for the "audience" as a whole is a mistake.

Posted: **Sat Jan 13, 2007 6:58 pm**

BadComrade wrote:
mw wrote:who is saying the albums "recorded at Electrical" aren't " really produced"?

Well, I'm pretty sure Steve would. He isn't a "producer", which is why he refers to himself as an engineer.

A producer usually has a lot of input on the sound of a band on record. Watch the documentary of the making of Aerosmith's album Pump for example, and you'll see the producer telling them to change lyrics, guitar parts, etc. Listen to an album recorded by Phil Spector, and you'll hear the "Phil Spector sound". The only thing on a recording that might give away the fact that Steve recorded it is the sound of the drums, and that's not even always the case.

i'm not saying steve (or whoever ) does a shit job... i'm saying the production on pink floyd albums is...well... the production of a rock album

Posted: **Sat Jan 13, 2007 6:59 pm**

rocker654 wrote:Check his/her "joined" date. Hardly immediate.

Goodness. On top of everything else, mw spent enough time lurking to thoroughly scout the audience. This dedication to craft exceeds what i was even surmising!