Premier Rock Forum

Not for fun this time...if you are like me it will be not so easy to vote
i love both the bands.......so well it wasn't something so easy to do...
at the end i decide to vote for Joy Division...
eh eh few years ago my point of view was different...

Damn this one is a real pickle. I listen to Joy Division more often, but I listen to way more bands directly influenced by Birthday Party. I have to think about this more before voting.

The Birthday Party!!

Joy Division.

charliedon'tsurf wrote:Damn this one is a real pickle. I listen to Joy Division more often, but I listen to way more bands directly influenced by Birthday Party. I have to think about this more before voting.

yeah it's not easy but i'm sure you will make it!
the Birthday Party has been one of the most cool bands ever....
...i can say almost like the Stooges...so well...

I love Joy Division, and probably listen to them more often. (I know that will appall some people around here.)

But it's the Birthday Party. C'mon.

not the easiest choice, but i went with The Birthday Party...

This video pretty much sums up my feelings on the subject. It's also hysterical:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEkkV1kgyd0

Tough call, but I'm going to go with the Birthday Party.

Joy Division.