The Cure
Radiohead
Bands that would have been-would be better w- no singing
2Sorry Capn', but this one is easy:
-RUSH
Also,
-most King Crimson
-RUSH
Also,
-most King Crimson
Bands that would have been-would be better w- no singing
3The Fucking Champs
Trans Am
Spaceboy
Speedealer
Metallica
I could, and probably will, go on.
Trans Am
Spaceboy
Speedealer
Metallica
I could, and probably will, go on.
Rick Reuben wrote:You are dumber than week-old donuts.
Bands that would have been-would be better w- no singing
4I agree 100% with radiohead. With no vocals I might even listen to an entire song.
Smashing Pumpkins
Tool & APC
Those VU songs that nico sang on.
Smashing Pumpkins
Tool & APC
Those VU songs that nico sang on.
simmo wrote:Someone make my carrot and grapefruits smoke. Please.
Bands that would have been-would be better w- no singing
5Led Zeppelin
Frank Zappa
Skinny Puppy
Queens Of The Stone Age
I also agree with the following :
Metallica
Rush
The Cure
Radiohead
I would be a huge Led Zeppelin fan if they were an instrumental group.
Frank Zappa
Skinny Puppy
Queens Of The Stone Age
I also agree with the following :
Metallica
Rush
The Cure
Radiohead
I would be a huge Led Zeppelin fan if they were an instrumental group.
Bands that would have been-would be better w- no singing
7I agree with each band in this thread (excepting shagboy's little joke). And what I'm about to say will probably offend you, but I'll add, the Jesus Lizard.
Yow trivialized their music with his hokey clown act. He blustered his way through every song with the same meaningless schtick and as a consequence all their songs 'feel' vey similar.
It's not that he couldn't sing. 'All my favorite singers can't sing.' It's that every song sets the same mood because of him. And it's not a mood that runs very deep. It's superficial and already sounds dated. This band hasn't aged well for me because of the vocals.
I would listen to this band much more, and take much more from the music if it weren't for the groggy-voiced 'crazy guy' shrieking about nothing all the time.
Yow trivialized their music with his hokey clown act. He blustered his way through every song with the same meaningless schtick and as a consequence all their songs 'feel' vey similar.
It's not that he couldn't sing. 'All my favorite singers can't sing.' It's that every song sets the same mood because of him. And it's not a mood that runs very deep. It's superficial and already sounds dated. This band hasn't aged well for me because of the vocals.
I would listen to this band much more, and take much more from the music if it weren't for the groggy-voiced 'crazy guy' shrieking about nothing all the time.
Bands that would have been-would be better w- no singing
8LAD wrote:I agree with each band in this thread (excepting shagboy's little joke). And what I'm about to say will probably offend you, but I'll add, the Jesus Lizard.
Yow trivialized their music with his hokey clown act. He blustered his way through every song with the same meaningless schtick and as a consequence all their songs 'feel' vey similar.
It's not that he couldn't sing. 'All my favorite singers can't sing.' It's that every song sets the same mood because of him. And it's not a mood that runs very deep. It's superficial and already sounds dated. This band hasn't aged well for me because of the vocals.
I would listen to this band much more, and take much more from the music if it weren't for the groggy-voiced 'crazy guy' shrieking about nothing all the time.
That's a very, very good point.
Bands that would have been-would be better w- no singing
10Sabbath
Ruins
Also agree with
Rush
Metallica (see Apocalyptica's '...Plays Metallica On 4 Cellos' - every song spoiled by the lead cello folllwoing the vocal line)
Disagree with
Radiohead
Jesus Lizard
Maybe I just like whining and atonal shrieking
Ruins
Also agree with
Rush
Metallica (see Apocalyptica's '...Plays Metallica On 4 Cellos' - every song spoiled by the lead cello folllwoing the vocal line)
Disagree with
Radiohead
Jesus Lizard
Maybe I just like whining and atonal shrieking