Well I think it's a great idea personally.

i agree - the debut album is always the best.

For some, maybe.

I agree. Watching a band grow, mature, and refine their sound over the years is fucking pointless. No one has ever released an album that has matched their debut, ever. Ever ever. Nope. never.

I disagree with the "debut album is always the best" statement. Although, alot of bands greatest work is often early on in their career.

whatever. still, if you knew you only had one release with your band music would be so much better.

DrAwkward wrote:I agree. Watching a band grow, mature, and refine their sound over the years is fucking pointless. No one has ever released an album that has matched their debut, ever. Ever ever. Nope. never.

Yeah. What homeboy said.

Yeah, screw "Highway 61", "In On The Killtaker", "Chairs Missing", "Closer", "In Utero", "Free Jazz", "Blood On The Tracks", "Revolver", "10,000 Light Years", "Solid Gold", "My War", "Bedtime For Democracy", Double Nickels...".








Bad Idea.

i don't think bands should be allowed to make one album.

i think that first album should be the deciding factor of:

1. if the debut even gets to be released
2. whether or not they get to make a second one.

Little Atlas Heavyweight wrote:i don't think bands should be allowed to make one album.

i think that first album should be the deciding factor of:

1. if the debut even gets to be released

The first album is the debut.