penningtron wrote:
I haven’t kept up in a few weeks but wasn’t the move to force Hochul’s hand in the matter? They knew the city council wouldn’t approve a property tax hike. Centrists just want more austerity measures. If they’re playing hardball, he’ll take back his endorsement and (at least by current polling measures) she’d be toast. It’s certainly an interesting tactic.
Sure. But that doesn't change what a profoundly dumb idea it is.
Three reasons:
1. The mere mention of it is already pissing off the working-class homeowners who voted for him, particularly low-information people who aren't gonna bother to read between the lines or call him on his bluff. I mean, there is a small chance it could actually happen, as well. Plus, working-class homeowners end up looking like cheap pawns in his game at very best.
2. It's yet another of these weird things he acts like he can do on his own as mayor, but actually cannot.
3. The progressive left—hell, not even the left, the most middling of Democrats—have a serious image problem in America w/people thinking they're gonna raise taxes on the middle class. And so the optics on this don't really do anything to dispel that myth.
Never mind that Hochul won't likely budge. Per that link in The City:
"Hochul didn’t blink, remaining steadfast in her refusal. And so Mamdani’s chances of forcing the governor to change course depend on the perception that he would, if forced, actually raise property taxes — and that he even could.
Now, as the mayor’s supporters fan out to press his case, they are being met with widespread skepticism on both fronts.
Andrea Scarborough, a homeowner in Addisleigh Park in southeastern Queens, told THE CITY that she flipped out when she heard about Mamdani’s gambit.
“Because you’re not able to raise taxes on the 1%, you’re looking to burden your constituents? I see it as a game of chicken, where you’re poking the governor,” she said. “I can’t imagine that this man would really want to do this, but if he does, he would be a one-term mayor.”
It's just dopey politics all around.