Premier Rock Forum

Aerosmith: not crap (there, I said it)
Beck: not crap
Clash, The: crap
Doors, The: not crap
Guns 'n' Roses: crap
Pixies, The: not crap
Public Enemy: crap
Smiths, The: not crap
Who, The: not crap
ZZ Top: crap
AC/DC: crap - oooh, not crap? Crap.
The Cure: crap
Siouxsie and the Banshees: not crap
Stereolab: crap
King Crimson: crap
Tom Waits: not crap
Ministry: crap
Replacements: crap
Tom Petty: crap
Black Flag: crap
Van Halen: crap flambe
Manowar: crap
The Cars: not sure
Leonard Cohen: not crap
Rod McEwan: crap
The Troggs: crap
Grateful Dead: crap
John Spencer Blues Explosion: not crap
Ornette Coleman: crap
Jeff Buckley: crap
Stevie Ray Vaughn & Double Trouble: ha! crap
My Bloody Valentine: not crap
Tortoise: not crap
Dinosaur Jr: crap
Built to Spill: crap
Chavez: crap
Smashing Pumpkins: crap. Crap:drink ratio - crap decreases as booze increases.
The Flaming Lips: not crap
swans: crap
devo: crap
gang of four: not crap. not crap. not crap
stranglers: not crap. or maybe, no - not crap
Public Image LTD: crap
Daniel Johnston: crap
Cheap Trick: not crap
The Velvet Underground: not crap
Elvis Costello: crap, mainly
Beatles, The: Largely quite crap
Black Sabbath: crap
Bowie, David: crap often
Dylan, Bob: crap
Led Zeppelin: not crap
Nirvana: ouch. Not crap
Presley, Elvis: crap
Rolling Stones, The: crap - good lord, crap.
Sex Pistols, The: crap, but not crap because they're crap
Sonic Youth: not crap
DEAD KENNEDYS: crap
NEIL DIAMOND: crap
JOHN FAHEY: crap
ALBERT AYLER: crap
DEAD C: crap
MUMMIES: crap
THIN LIZZY: crap
NAPALM DEATH: crap
ABBA: crap
SMOG: not crap
CAN: not crap
TALKING HEADS: kkkkeeeeeeerap!
HERMANN NITSCH:who? Crap.
hendrix: not crap
alice cooper: crap
beastie boys: Crap of the most putrid kind.
funkadelic: Never heard of them. But with a name like that... not crap
fugazi: not crap
radiohead: not crap (it's a sunny day)
fleetwood mac: crap
Nina Simone: not crap
Frank Sinatra: a flaming crap in a bag on one's doorstep
Kraftwerk: not crap
Aphex Twin: not crap
Unwound: crap
Tool: crap
Superchunk: err, crap!
Air: crapulationsville
The Dirty Three: crap

In a similar way to amos, and in the most arrogant way I can muster, I must assume that anything of which I am unfamiliar is crap. Just to be fair.

I'd like to thank you for forcing me to be so merciless in my tastes. I'm now off to sell/burn all of my CDs and records, and invest in some Westlife.

I'm also surprised that there's been no mention as yet of Pink Floyd.

Pink Floyd: crap

Thanks

John

Big Black-notcrap

Rapeman-crrrnot crap

Aerosmith:crap
Beck:crap
Clash, The:crap
Doors, The:crap
Guns 'n' Roses:not crap
Pixies, The:crap
Public Enemy:crap
Smiths, The:crap
Who, The:not crap
ZZ Top:not crap
Replacements: crap
Tom Petty: crap
Black Flag: crap
Van Halen: not crap
Manowar: crap
The Cars: crap
Leonard Cohen:crap
Rod McEwan: ?
The Troggs:?
Grateful Dead:crap
John Spencer Blues Explosion:crap
Ornette Coleman:not crap
Jeff Buckley:crap
Stevie Ray Vaughn & Double Trouble:crap
My Bloody Valentine:crap
Tortoise:not crap
Dinosaur Jr:not crap
Built to Spill:crap
Chavez:crap
Smashing Pumpkins:crap
The Flaming Lips:crrraap
Unwound: notcrap
Tool:craap
Superchunk:crap
Air:crap
The Dirty Three:crap
Fleetwood Mac:crap

What kind of elitist bullshit game is this, anyways?

A certain proprietor of EA slashing Nirvana? Jeez, you've started to really bitter in your old age, man! What about all of that "In Utero" gushing you did?

I know there's a lot of SA ass-kissing on here so I'll be the first to stop it

How about: "New Number Order": TOTAL FUCKING CRAP!

This game is fun.
Beach Boys:
Dead Boys:

Aerosmith: crap
Beck: crap
Clash, The: decidedly not crap
Doors, The: crap
Guns 'n' Roses: crap
Pixies, The: not crap
Public Enemy: not crap
Smiths, The: crap
Who, The: not crap
ZZ Top: not crap

I'm surprised at how many people put PE as 'crap' - I think they are standing in for all hip-hop on this board, which is a bit unfair. So...

NWA:
De La Soul:
The Roots:
Jurassic 5ive:
Chicago Bears Shufflin' Crew:
Run-DMC:
Common:
EPMD:
Eric B & Rakim:
Geto Boys:

AC/DC: not crap, ever
The Cure: crap
Soixisue(SP) and the Banshees: yep, crap
Stereolab: oh, so much crap
King Crimson: not crap, strangely
Tom Waits: not crap
Ministry: crap

i'm a little late, but...

Aerosmith: CRAP
Beck: not crap
Clash, The: not crap
Doors, The: not crap
Guns 'n' Roses: CRAP
Pixies, The: not crap
Public Enemy: CRAP
Smiths, The: CRAP
Who, The: not crap
ZZ Top: CRAP

end of discussion.

andyk

cheer accident:



oop!

cheer accident: not crap
Grateful Dead: CRAP
John Spencer Blues Explosion: CRAP
Ornette Coleman: not crap
Jeff Buckley: not crap
Stevie Ray Vaughn & Double Trouble: CRAP
My Bloody Valentine: CRAP
Tortoise: not crap
Dinosaur Jr: CRAP
Built to Spill: CRAP
Chavez: CRAP
Smashing Pumpkins: CRAP
The Flaming Lips: not crap
AC/DC: CRAP
The Cure: CRAP
Siouxsie and the Banshees: CRAP
Stereolab: CRAP
King Crimson: CRAP
Tom Waits: CRAP
Ministry: CRAP
Replacements: CRAP
Tom Petty: not crap
Black Flag: not crap
Van Halen: CRAP
Manowar: CRAP
The Cars: CRAP
Leonard Cohen: CRAP
Rod McEwan: CRAP
The Troggs: CRAP
swans: CRAP
devo: CRAP
gang of four: not crap
stranglers: CRAP
Public Image LTD: not crap
Daniel Johnston: CRAP
Cheap Trick: CRAP
The Velvet Underground: not crap
Elvis Costello: CRAP

thank you-
andyk