I usually chime in with the 'Oliver Twist'

"Thank you, may I please have some more?"

I've never thanked anyone, nor have I been thanked by anyone else...or I don't remember either type of exchange having taken place. The idea never even occurred to me. Now I'm thinking, shit dude, if they don't say thanks is this a bad sign? Or is it a bad sign to thank/be thanked? Like, "Thank you so much for the sex, I never get laid". Guess it depends on the situation, though I tend to think in dichotomies, so I can't much help but divide it up like that.

fishingrhod wrote:

2207 wrote:siwr iawn.

simach fach ti

dim chwys. diolch.

The Mercy Fuck is thirsting
And I think my balls are bursting...

I am reminded of one girl I was seeing for awhile, she spoke not so much the good English.
After an extremely vigorous boinking one evening, we are sitting on the couch smoking a joint watching the Portishead DVD and she says 'Thank you very much for the...' then pounds her fist into her hand a few times 'for the pounding, it came in handy. I had a lot of stress, now I'm calm'
Those were her exact words.
Thank you so much for the pounding, it came in handy. I had a lot of stress, now I am calm.
It's rolled around in my head a million different ways ever since and I have come to the conclusion that it's most likely the most awesome thing ever.

This seems like clapping for the pilot after touchdown.

If I'm allowed to make that completely retarded analogy.

Marsupialized wrote:I am reminded of one girl I was seeing for awhile, she spoke not so much the good English.
After an extremely vigorous boinking one evening, we are sitting on the couch smoking a joint watching the Portishead DVD and she says 'Thank you very much for the...' then pounds her fist into her hand a few times 'for the pounding, it came in handy. I had a lot of stress, now I'm calm'
Those were her exact words.
Thank you so much for the pounding, it came in handy. I had a lot of stress, now I am calm.
It's rolled around in my head a million different ways ever since and I have come to the conclusion that it's most likely the most awesome thing ever.

That is pretty cool. Now think of it again but with Michael Wincott's voice.

iembalm wrote:

Marsupialized wrote:I am reminded of one girl I was seeing for awhile, she spoke not so much the good English.
After an extremely vigorous boinking one evening, we are sitting on the couch smoking a joint watching the Portishead DVD and she says 'Thank you very much for the...' then pounds her fist into her hand a few times 'for the pounding, it came in handy. I had a lot of stress, now I'm calm'
Those were her exact words.
Thank you so much for the pounding, it came in handy. I had a lot of stress, now I am calm.
It's rolled around in my head a million different ways ever since and I have come to the conclusion that it's most likely the most awesome thing ever.

That is pretty cool. Now think of it again but with Michael Wincott's voice.

When I think of it, I imagine Steve Perry or Dennis DeYoung singing it on stage in front of thousands of people, they are all going wild.

I knew a lady who said "Thank you" during the act.

That was very much NOT CRAP.

Is is just the "thank" phrases in particular that has everyone wigged out?

What about compliments in general? If you vote 'CRAP' on thanking, would you also vote 'CRAP' on random compliments?

IF YOU'RE DOING IT RIGHT - if you're really putting in 110% effort, there's no telling what words might fly out of your mouth or your partner's mouth, either during the act or just afterwards... if you're really encouraging each other to "loosen up" and "lose yourselves" for a bit, then who the fuck is lame enough to keep score and hold someone accountable for some shit that they said?

Way to overthink this one, rockers.